Do-It-Yourself Food in Holmes Beach, FL

Fresh reviews:

Stopped in with my mom to check out what they had and ended up getting a piece of their key lime pie to share. Let me just say — we should have gotten TWO pieces. It was, hands down, the best key lime pie I’ve ever had — fresh and tart and so creamy… I wish I had more right now!

Sara S.

Island Fresh Market

We come to the island every summer and are froyo fanatics, so we are so glad we found this place! Cute set up, nice selection for salad and froyo toppings, and the owner was very nice! We will definitely be frequenting Stir it Up much more often!