The 10 Best Pizza in Caldwell, ID

Fresh reviews:

My family and I go here often. We all really enjoy it and the staff is always in a great mood:) they also usally have awesome coupons.

Calli R.

Papa Murphy’s Take’n’bake Pizza

Pizza is great and so is the service! The staff is always so friendly. Our little family loves this place!

Lizeth S.

Garbonzo’s

Some of the best pizza in town. I like how they have kept up with the dining experience, and still care about their customers. Pizza is a little more pricey, but well worth it!

Nate B.

Idaho Pizza Company

Don’t let the run down decrepit building fool you, best pizza in Caldwell… much better than Mancino’s or Idaho pizza!

Don L.

Keystone Pizza

It has pretty yummy food. I never stay and eat, just get it to go. But the pizza is always good, I really love pizzas with garlic sauce and I was impressed when it was on the menu! It would be nice if the pizzas weren’t so greasy. You about have to use a napkin to soak up all the grease before you can eat but I…

Taylor B.

Pizza Hut

Some of their rules are stupid! If I am going to pay for something, I think I deserve to have it the way I want it. nope not here its their way or no way. Alls we wanted was a half and half pizza and the guy informed me they don’t do they. So needless to say that was my first and last time going here.

Calli R.

Papa John’s Pizza

I grab a pizza from here probably every other month and get either a decent only two hour old pizza, a very old pizza, or a pizza with almost not cheese almost no sauce and always under cooked. Go to the Nampa location and you will have a little better luck.