The Top 10 Pizza in Idaho Falls, ID

Fresh reviews:

The first slice I had of Papa Toms pizza was over 30 years ago and all I can remember is I wanted more and more as it was full of flavor and different. The sauce is like no other sauce I have ever tasted as it makes the pizza taste so good. I call it «The Secret Pizza Sauce». I have had many friends work there…

Ben B.

Papa Tom’s Pizza

A serious drop in quality from when they were in Ririe. Out of parm, out of their imported sausage, out of everything good. Gone are the days of the (perfectly) slightly charred pizza of stoplight pizza. Now the pizza is pretty average and hard to respect. Feels like tom let this place go.I left a 5 star review…

Eli U.

Stoplight Pizza

I had been to this place a few times when they first opened and it was great. I went yesterday for my birthday and was very disappointed. My prospector burger was bland and supposedly had bacon cooked into the pattie but there was none, I had to request a couple pieces of bacon to put on my dry burger. It was…

Matt P.

MacKenzie River Pizza, Grill & Pub

We went to Lucy’s last night with our granddaughter, at her recommendation that it was the best place for pizza in Idaho Falls. The food was good, but the service was very bad. It was disorganized and slow. We waited for even water for about 20 minutes before we flagged down a wait person and asked to be waited…

Tim F.

Lucy’s New York Style Pizzeria

I ordered here twice since my last review and I literally got sick. My friend and I couldn’t even eat the whole slice… I don’t know what’s going on but the cheese tastes funky

Mandi G.

Lucy’s Pizzeria

I don’t know how this place makes it. Ok pizza but never very organized and slower than molasses. This has been happening for years. I will never go back. Hour and a half for two mini pizzas for lunch. I had to go back to work and said we had to leave. Said we weren’t paying for anything. They said, let us give…

Kelly H.

Pizza Hut

14 places in Idaho Falls, ordered by rating:

Papa Murphy’s

5.0

1 review

Telephone:	+1 208-528-9800
Address:	1857 W Broadway St

Pizza /

Domino’s Pizza

4.6

5 reviews

Telephone:	+1 208-523-7530
Address:	945 W Broadway St

Pizza / Chicken Wings / Sandwiches

Mangini’s Take-N-Bake

4.3

3 reviews

Telephone:	+1 208-542-7681
Address:	525 2nd St

Desserts / Salad / Pizza

Lucy’s New York Style Pizzeria

4.2

20 reviews

Telephone:	+1 208-524-2800
Address:	725 E Anderson St

Pizza / Italian

Stoplight Pizza

4.0

6 reviews

Telephone:	+1 208-351-1179
Address:	775 Yellowstone Ave

Pizza /

Lucy’s Pizzeria

3.6

20 reviews

Telephone:	+1 844-280-1192
Address:	2770 S 25th E

Pizza / Italian

MacKenzie River Pizza, Grill & Pub

3.5

20 reviews

Telephone:	+1 208-932-2987
Address:	1490 Milligan Rd

Pizza / Sandwiches

Papa Tom’s Pizza

3.1

20 reviews

Telephone:	+1 208-523-6800
Address:	1830 S Woodruff Ave

Pizza / Sandwiches / Salad

Pizza Hut

1.6

8 reviews

Telephone:	+1 208-524-1211
Address:	2250 E 17th Street

Pizza / Italian / Chicken Wings

Sbarro

···

Telephone:	+1 208-522-8487
Address:	2300 E 17th St

Pizza / Desserts / Salad

Pizza Hut

···

Telephone:	+1 208-524-2727
Address:	725 E Anderson St

Pizza /

Papa Kelsey’s Pizza & Subs.

···

Telephone:	+1 208-524-8655
Address:	960 Northgate Mile

Sandwiches / Italian / Pizza

Franco’s Italian Pizzeria

···

Telephone:	+1 208-524-2088
Address:	150 1st St

Italian / Pizza

Pizza Hut

···

Telephone:	+1 208-523-7411
Address:	1970 W Broadway St

Pizza / Italian / Chicken Wings

The Top 10 Pizza

Idaho Falls, ID, United States

Fresh reviews:

14 places in Idaho Falls, ordered by rating: