The Top 10 Sandwiches in New Lenox, IL

Fresh reviews:

Love this place! Their Italian sausage is delicious and they have great sandwiches, hot and cold. Their prices are reasonable and their employees are always very friendly.

Margaret H.

Italia Imports Two

Great fast food restaurant, can call ahead to have food ready when u arrive, gyro plate comes with a generous amount of meat

Justin S.

Aj’s Hot Dogs & Gyros

I’ve been to Jersey Mikes many times and I pretty much get the same thing. #9 mike’s way no tomato. Every store that I’ve been to has consistently made the sandwich the same and I love that they slice the meat fresh in front of you. Cuts down on the feeling that you might get sick from meat sitting out to…

Diane D.

Jersey Mike’s Subs

I, too, worked at this location a while back and found it was disgusting. I read Laura M’s post and laughed because I agree. You could never clean too long without getting in trouble. This location has gone way down hill. I used to want subway morning, noon and night but now it repulses me because of how…

Ashley M.

Subway

PROS: Flavor, drive thru, and locationCONS: The management hires people who don’t know what 1⁄3 means. I asked for my sandwich to be 1⁄3 no cheese & cut at that spot. It was even marked on the yellow ticket. It was instead cut in ½ with just ½ cheese. Simple directions, people, simple directions. And as for…

Emma B.

Potbelly Sandwich Shop

I got the #4 (turkey) and the meat has a plastic look on it. I know it’s not quality meat. But come on.

Chelsea H.

Jimmy John’s

What a joke. We got here at four. Upon arriving we noticed the girl that greets you in the front and shows your to your seat was standing in the corner (away from the view of the camera) on her phone and bolted to her station when she heard us walk in. That’s fine, whatever. We were seated. The waiter came out…

Marwa G.

IHOP

14 places in New Lenox, ordered by rating:

Italia Imports Two

4.8

8 reviews

Telephone:	+1 815-463-9870
Address:	13150 W Lincoln Hwy Ste 5

Delis / Sandwiches

Hope’s Kitchen

4.7

6 reviews

Telephone:	+1 815-463-8875
Address:	138 E Francis Rd

American (New) / Sandwiches

JBD White Horse Inn

3.8

12 reviews

Telephone:	+1 815-485-4848
Address:	348 W Maple St

Dive Bars / Sandwiches / Pizza

Jersey Mike’s Subs

4.0

20 reviews

Telephone:	+1 815-463-0521
Address:	527 E Lincoln Hwy

Fast Food / Sandwiches / Delis

Tropical Smoothie Café

4.1

8 reviews

Telephone:	+1 815-717-8095
Address:	1872 E Lincoln Hwy

Breakfast & Brunch / Sandwiches / Cafes

Potbelly Sandwich Shop

3.7

7 reviews

Telephone:	+1 815-320-7388
Address:	571 E Lincoln Hwy

Sandwiches / Salad / Caterers

Mattina Cafe

3.6

20 reviews

Telephone:	+1 815-463-9223
Address:	426 E Lincoln Hwy

American (New) / Breakfast & Brunch / Sandwiches

Aj’s Hot Dogs & Gyros

3.5

20 reviews

Telephone:	+1 815-485-8922
Address:	342 W Maple St

Sandwiches / American (New)

Jimmy John’s

3.6

8 reviews

Telephone:	+1 815-485-2725
Address:	2334 E Lincoln Hwy

Sandwiches /

Subway

3.0

6 reviews

Telephone:	+1 815-463-0400
Address:	338 W Maple St

Sandwiches / Fast Food

IHOP

3.2

15 reviews

Telephone:	+1 815-717-6373
Address:	411 E Lincoln Hwy

Breakfast & Brunch / Sandwiches

Lou Malnati’s Pizzeria

···

Telephone:	+1 815-900-7450
Address:	2510 E Lincoln Hwy

Pizza / Italian / Sandwiches

Subway

···

Telephone:	+1 815-463-0400
Address:	334 W Maple St

Sandwiches / Fast Food

The Top 10 Sandwiches

New Lenox, IL, United States

Fresh reviews:

14 places in New Lenox, ordered by rating: