The 20 Best Pizza in Anderson, IN

Fresh reviews:

This is where I go when we get the urge for pizza. The sandwiches are just as good. Prices are reasonable. You won’t be able to go back to chain store pizza after eating here. The staff is also really friendly which is always a plus.

Pam G.

Art’s Pizza

I really love Greek’s pizza. It is my favorite place to order take out at. This location has always done a great job with getting the order right and getting it to us before the time they say it’ll be ready.My boyfriend has gone in for their buffet and he really seems to like it. He used to work close by and it…

Randi R.

Greek’s Pizzaria

Every Mancino’s I find anymore always seems to be empty. This one was no different, although at 9PM during the week that may play into this.I have never HATED the food at Mancino’s and the toasted subs (grinders) are usually good. We used to go to the one occasionally in Noblesville before they closed and I…

Chris G.

Mancino’s

I really love Pizza King when the food is made with care. That being said, over the past few years, the quality has been getting worse and worse. Not just at this particular location, but at every Pizza King in Anderson, IN. I don’t think it’s the quality of the actual food that’s the problem… I think it’s the…

Meredith A.

Pizza King

Problems, problems, problems … They always seem to have some issue! Eat in and it is all good! Delivery and it is all bad! Long wait times and constant turn over!

Thomas M.

Pizza King

Worst Pizza Hut that I have ever been to. My boyfriend loves Pizza Hut wings and deep dish pizza. So whenever we order pizza it is usually Pizza Hut. We moved around here in June. We have ordered from this Pizza Hut three times. Each time they have completely messed up the order and were rude about it.On the…

Randi R.

Pizza Hut

This place is absolutely horrible. It is too much to even list the number of issues we have had with this location including the driver looking through our window to «see our dogs». They charge a ridiculous amount for add ons that they almost always forget and the management is clearly some poorly educated and…