The Top 10 Pizza in Chesterton, IN

Fresh reviews:

Haven’t been here in years but tried it by chance today. So glad I did! I haven’t paid so little for a kids meal in a long time and they got A LOT of food! The stuffed hot beef sandwich is HUGE and delicious! It’s not common in 2016 to find this great of a value when dining out! Our server, Eli, was great as…

Joe C.

Val’s Famous Pizza & Grinders

So we stopped at a new-to-us pizza place in Chesterton (AJ’s Pizza) for dinner tonight. I must say they had some of the most interesting pizza on the menu. Some I have never seen before. Since I am a real sucker for Reuben sandwiches I had to get the Reuben pizza. Delicious but it is only a short-time…

Rick S.

AJ’s Pizza Co

Fantastic pizza and excellent appetizers, but at Richie Rich prices. I always want it, but never want to pay *that* much for a pizza.

Aaron L.

Gelsosomo’s Pizzeria

This place is closed forever. Sign on the door as of March 1, 2016 the restaurant was closed. Still doing catering I guess

Adam N.

Popolano’s Restaurant

My lady and I visited here on 5⁄21 and I definetly won’t be back. I ordered a chicken sandwhich and when it arrived, 2 bites into it I find that the inside is still gooey and uncooked chicken. I politely notified the waitress and she looked it it, commented how gross that is and apologized, then took my plate…