The 20 Best Pizza in Columbus, IN

Fresh reviews:

Best breadsticks with spicy cheese sauce! Always stop on my way back to Bloomington, IN.

Jessica M.

They have decent pizza & the beer is getting betterThink the price of the pizza is a couple $$$ to high for what you get & can be very slow of busy & the pizza always seems to come out undercooked

Todd B.

450 North Brewery & Brix Haus Restaurant

Clean food. Decent service. Big salads. Typical college town in that you have to get the right wait staff as some are indifferent. Pepperoni bread is good too.

Jay C.

Puccini’s Smiling Teeth Pizza & Pasta

The pizza was decent. We also had a Philly cheesteak but it was more like a French dip sub. It was delicious but drenched in juice and some sauce. Overall a decent place.

Katrina A.

Arni’s

The pizza was so-so but the beer and ambience were nice. Others at the table commented that they’ve «had worse» hoagies. But we were quite disappointed by the salad that arrived in a cold box with packaged Kraft dressing. Then we had to eat in styrofoam plates with plastic utensils. Wanted a nicer/classier…

A K.

Zwanzigz Pizza

They shorted us cheese, forgot to give us 2-liter, the cheese was supposed to be pan pizza and the pepperoni was supposed to be thin and crispy they confused the two for the second time. The cheese pizza was over cooked while the pepperoni was under cooked. The breadsticks were also over cooked. The people…

Becca B.

Pizza Hut

I arrived at 7:50 pm to order a couple of pizzas. After paying I noticed all the ingredients were removed from the bar and placed in plastic containers and stacked on a cart. The young man who waited on me began to start fumbling through the containers to start locating the toppings needed to make my pizza…