The 20 Best Pizza in Evansville, IN

Fresh reviews:

Best pizza I’ve had I a long time love the bacon and cheese and their bread sticks. Their sandwiches are great also. We order out a lot where I work at and its always hot when we get it.

Makayla S.

Gardo’s Italian Oven

Our favorite pizza for sure. Love the ambiance of all the locations. Cheesey bread is our go to app.

Chris B.

Turoni’s Forget-Me-Not Inn

Stopped in to get a pizza and some wings both were done right. After all it’s Pizza Hut so that said what made this visit great was the friendly chat with Zach the manager and him talking me into trying this new s’mores cookie that’s coming out. I mean I’m not even really into cookies but this cookie well it…

Chuck R.

Pizza Hut

Tasted just like my dad’s homemade pizzas. If you are in evansville Indiana you need to try it. Locally owned and operated. Has great service and good food. Happy I stopped here. Lost my dad 2 yrs ago and this was heart warming to eat something that reminded me of him.

John T.

Deerhead Sidewalk Cafe

I would’ve given this place a 5-Star review if it wasn’t for the initial service my family received. We were greeted, placed in a seat, and then handed our menus. One would assume a waiter/waitress would come and request our drink orders, however this was not the case. We were not served for over 10 minutes…

Chase T.

Old Chicago

Used to be my favorite stromboli, but not even the third best in Evansville anymore. I used to love them so much, so i gave them several chances after my first skimpy strom. the first bad one looked and tasted like it had no cheese. I complained and received a free one on my next visit, weeks later, the strom…

Pete D.

Pizza King

The ONLY reason I am giving two stars instead of one is because of the quick response and handling of the situation by the manager. My boyfriend and I had never been to Smitty’s before and decided to try them out. We were sat quickly at a table. Shortly after, a female approached with another girl behind her…