The Top 10 Pizza in Monticello, IN

Fresh reviews:

We order delivery from here pretty often and I can’t say that I have any complaints. The delivery driver will still take deliveries even when it’s really close to closing time and the food always arrives within 30 minutes. The drivers are always friendly and the food is of decent quality.

Jessie L.

Pizza Hut

Decided to stop and get pizza to hot to cook to find out the a/c wasn’t working so felt like an oven inside! We decided to make our own fans and just enjoy relaxing time. The pizza was excellent as always but the waitress on the other hand didn’t even take the time to check on us so we had to go up for refills…

Sherry C.

Monicals’s Pizza

Sketchy on the outside. Inside wasn’t much better. Smelled like smoke. Asked if the 312 beer was an IPA to the bartender, with response «what’s an IPA?». Interesting people. Definately locals. Had baby back ribs and they were decent, but not awesome.

Tom G.

Beaver’s Pub

There food is really good. We’ve tried the pizza and a few sandwiches and everything was delicious. Our kids really enjoyed it too.My only problem with this restaurant is that they keep their servers tips. They pay them above minimum wage and don’t allow them to keep the tips they receive. This practice is not…

Nikki W.

The Scoreboard

I went to sit down when I found gum on my butt. I had gum on my butt. And poop was smeared on my table. Yummy very appetizing. The food tasted like srirachi sauce. I would have rather went to the movie theater and eaten Popcorn off the floor. Why do places in town love poop?!

Chloe P.

Abe’s Pizza

Very disappointed in the pizza. Tasted like a cardboard pizza I could have picked up at the local Kroger. And the sausage was just crumbled on top. Mozzarella Sticks weren’t very good either. Not sure how this place can call themselves «king». The kids didn’t even want seconds.