The 20 Best Pizza in Warsaw, IN

Fresh reviews:

A meal at the historic Barbee Hotel never disappoints. You can always count on great food, good service, and an awesome beer selection.

Natalie F.

Barbee Hotel Restaurant & Bar

What can I say LOCAL LOCAL LOCAL, in the best possible way. Love it. Burgers are amazing yum. It’s the best dive ever. People are cool and chilled. It’s a fully stocked bar. Steak fries yum. I went with the mushroom Swiss with bacon.. Bartender RAE is very cool. If you are ever in WARSAW IN come here worth…

Jose C.

Rex’s Rendezvous

We had given up on finding a decent pizza in Warsaw. The we found Angelo. Don’t let the surly tattooed staff scare you these people know their shit.This is the ONLY pizza place in Warsaw. Forget the papa and crapinos. This plus their Chicago style sandwiches are amazing.Go you won’t regret it.

Scott T.

Angelo’s Pizza

Things have changed here since my last review in 2012. It’s saddening because this used to be THE Pizza Hut to go to around here. Here recently the service is lacking majorly. When we order delivery it is never correct nor on time. Whether placed online or called in. We order delivery almost every week and…

Britni T.

Pizza Hut

Standing in the lobby and I can already tell that I am not going to enjoy this experience. The woman behind the counter acted as if I was a second-rate human when I walked in. You only get one chance at a first impression and I must say. This was not a good one. If you don’t enjoy your job or life in general…

Clint N.

Gambie’s Pizza

Are… you…kidding me???I have a pizza minus one slice sitting on my kitchen counter right now. I ordered the… you know what?It doesn’t matter what I ordered. If you are excited to see that Greek’s has expanded to Warsaw and have eaten at other locations, DO NOT get excited.Oh my gosh… where to…

Constant S.

Greek’s Pizzeria

18 places in Warsaw, ordered by rating:

Barbee Hotel Restaurant & Bar

4.4

7 reviews

Telephone:	+1 574-834-1111
Address:	3620 N Barbee Rd

Soup / Pizza / Sandwiches

Danny’s Pizza

4.0

6 reviews

Telephone:	+1 574-834-1111
Address:	3620 North Barbee Road

Pizza /

Papa John’s Pizza

3.8

5 reviews

Telephone:	+1 574-269-3200
Address:	2511 E Center St

Pizza /

Rex’s Rendezvous

4.2

6 reviews

Telephone:	+1 574-267-5066
Address:	204 S Buffalo St

American (Traditional) / Pizza / Breakfast & Brunch

Pizza Hut

4.0

1 review

Telephone:	+1 574-269-6650
Address:	3314 Lake City Hwy

Pizza / Italian / Chicken Wings

Gambie’s Pizza

4.0

5 reviews

Telephone:	+1 574-269-1801
Address:	830 E Winona Ave

Pizza / Sandwiches

Angelo’s Pizza

4.0

13 reviews

Telephone:	+1 574-268-2333
Address:	2568 Walton Rd

Pizza /

Domino’s Pizza

3.5

2 reviews

Telephone:	+1 574-269-5757
Address:	202 N Detroit St

Pizza / Chicken Wings / Sandwiches

Pizza Hut

3.4

5 reviews

Telephone:	+1 574-269-2008
Address:	502 N Detroit St

Pizza / Italian / Chicken Wings

Pizza King

3.4

7 reviews

Telephone:	+1 574-269-1631
Address:	1039 E Winona Ave

Pizza /

Greek’s Pizzeria

3.7

7 reviews

Telephone:	+1 574-269-1113
Address:	101 E Center St

Greek / Pizza

Pizza Supply of Indiana

···

Telephone:	+1 574-267-5439
Address:	2162 N Cessna Rd

Pizza /

Clara’s Pizza King

···

Telephone:	+1 574-269-1631
Address:	1039 E Winona Ave

Pizza /

Little Caesars

···

Telephone:	+1 574-269-1212
Address:	101 E Winona

Pizza /

Elmo’s

···

Telephone:	+1 574-371-2050
Address:	1900 Plaza Dr

Pizza /

Elmo’s Pizza and Subs

···

Telephone:	+1 574-267-5761
Address:	777 Parker Street

Pizza / Sandwiches

Pizza King

···

Telephone:	+1 574-269-5464
Address:	1727 W Lake St

Pizza /

Elmo’s Pizza and Subs

···

Telephone:	+1 574-371-2050
Address:	1900 Plaza Dr

Pizza / Sandwiches

Pizza in nearby cities:

Ligonier

The 20 Best Pizza

Warsaw, IN, United States

Fresh reviews:

18 places in Warsaw, ordered by rating:

Pizza in nearby cities: