American (New) in Wellesley, MA

Fresh reviews:

I have now tried this place three times, and I can only reach one conclusion. The Cottage combines mediocre, overpriced food with generally poor service. I won’t be trying it again.

Reid F.

The Cottage

I’m in a seat I had to wipe off myself for fear of sitting in the remains of the last three or four meals eaten before my arrival. My drink feels permanently attached to the table because it’s so sticky. I’m watching one of the counter people aimlessly wipe a table near me with a disgustingly dirty rag, clearly…