The Top 10 Pizza in Middletown, NJ

Fresh reviews:

Have ordered takeout twice in the past week. Delicious food. Love the tacos. I could eat them every day. They taste fresh and remind me of some of the top taco trucks in NYC. Presentation is perfect. The burritos were tasty as well. We also tried some of the Italian food and the chicken cheesesteak California…

Christina C.

Tre Colore

Ordered food on a Saturday night and it was delivered to us in Hazlet in under an hour, nice and hot. The chicken franchise was awesome. Their grandma pizza the best. Great stop.

Michael G.

Pasquale’s Pizzeria III

I’m new to the area and haven’t had much luck finding decent pizza despite many personal recommendations, so some family and I figured we’d give Fratelli’s a shot given the positive feedback on Unilocal.They even boasted a #1 ranking for best pizza in Middletown featured on a rather dubious list of…

John S.

Fratelli’s Restaurant Pizzeria

I ordered chicken quesadillas. I kept thinking they didnt taste right. well apparently they didnt because i got food poisoning. Never again.

April S.

MJ’s Pizza Bar & Grill

This place is an absolute disaster. If you go to the restaurant, you’ll see there appears to be two owners, one a nice guy, and the other an obnoxious jerk. Ordering on the phone is hit-or-miss as well, with my most recent order being the last time I deal with these guys.I call the order in, and a different…

Jimmy S.

Villa Pizza

Okay so where do I begin with this?This place sucks… a lot. I guess I’ll start with the food and not my bad experience because I hate those people who come on here to rant (and that’s kind of me) but I’d rather tell you about how horrendous this food is first so you don’t think I’m heated for no reason. My…