The 10 Best Pizza

Nutley, NJ, United States

Open map

Fresh reviews:

I have only had the pizza. It is just ok. Nothing great about it, not bad but not great, just average. In Northern NJ, you have to do better. The regular pie price at $ 11 for pick-up is ok but their specialty pies are priced too high.

Joe A.

Loue’s Place Pizza & Pasta

3.5 stars– Great beers on tap. Loved the atmosphere of the place. What disappointed me was the pizza… It was very burnt on the bottom! Flavor wise it tasted good but wasn’t blown away. We also had the fried risotto balls which were amaaaaazing, and the prosciutto panini which was also delicious and smothered in…

Kelly K.

Luna Wood Fire Tavern

The food can be hit or miss but tonight was the all time worst. I ordered a meatball sub and thought if felt a little light when I picked it up. Once I got home and opened it, I couldn’t believe it. One meatball was cut into small slices and spread out across the bread. I won’t be ordering from Rocky’s again!

Angela K.

Rocky’s Restaurant & Pizzeria

Discount pizza.You get what you pay for. Do yourself a favor and pay a couple of dollars more for a properly cooked pizza.The girls taking the orders are completely inattentive and are more interested in music videos on TV. No wonder that have issues getting the orders correct.Don’t waste your time

Gus F.

Gencarelli Brothers

16 places in Nutley, ordered by rating:

Santini Pizzeria

5.0

1 review

Telephone:	+1 973-661-5205
Address:	355 Franklin Ave

Pizza / Italian

Loue’s Place Pizza & Pasta

4.0

20 reviews

Telephone:	+1 973-661-3333
Address:	185 High St

Pizza / Italian

Luna Wood Fire Tavern

4.2

20 reviews

Telephone:	+1 973-320-5935
Address:	223 Franklin Ave

Pizza / Italian / Bars

Nuovo Cucina Napoletana

3.6

8 reviews

Telephone:	+1 973-798-2426
Address:	633 Franklin Ave

Italian / Pizza

Ritacco Brothers Brick Oven Pizza

3.7

20 reviews

Telephone:	+1 973-667-9662
Address:	18 Washington Ave

Pizza /

Bell Paese Pizzeria

4.3

20 reviews

Telephone:	+1 973-667-8232
Address:	196 Franklin Ave

Delis / Pizza

Cucina 355

3.8

20 reviews

Telephone:	+1 973-798-4500
Address:	355 Franklin Ave

Italian / Pizza

Domino’s Pizza

3.6

12 reviews

Telephone:	+1 973-667-2222
Address:	36 Franklin Ave

Pizza / Chicken Wings / Sandwiches

Ralph’s Pizzeria & Restaurant

3.4

20 reviews

Telephone:	+1 973-235-1174
Address:	564 Franklin Ave

Italian / Pizza

Rocky’s Restaurant & Pizzeria

3.7

16 reviews

Telephone:	+1 973-667-2234
Address:	420 Franklin Ave

Pizza / Italian

Michael’s Pastaria & Deli

3.6

20 reviews

Telephone:	+1 973-661-5252
Address:	143 Franklin Ave

Delis / Italian / Pizza

Ferrulli Pizza

3.5

15 reviews

Telephone:	+1 973-667-7900
Address:	80 Centre St

Pizza / Sandwiches

Gencarelli Brothers

3.2

15 reviews

Telephone:	+1 973-667-3663
Address:	371 Centre St

Pizza /

Cabrina’s Pizzeria

2.5

10 reviews

Telephone:	+1 973-667-4414
Address:	307 Bloomfield Ave

Pizza /

Casa Turano Pizzeriza & Restaurant

2.5

11 reviews

Telephone:	+1 973-667-7333
Address:	660 Passaic Ave

Pizza /

Dileonardo’s Pizza & Fine Italian Dining Restaurant

···

Telephone:	+1 973-667-8222
Address:	481 Franklin Ave

Italian / Pizza

Pizza in nearby cities:

Jackson Heights

Paterson

West Bronx