The Top 10 Pizza in Rahway, NJ

Fresh reviews:

My family is keeping this place in business. We the pizza! We are Brooklyn born and this is as close as it gets in Rahway!

Charisse Y.

Nunzios II

You know why I like this place? They have a great selection of really good pizza UNTIL CLOSING TIME! The pizza is very good, their sandwiches are huge, the staff are friendly and quick. Odd corner for parking, but it doable. Never had delivery, so can’t speak to that. Definitely one of the best slice joints…

Bryan J.

Tony’s Pizza Cafe

have been eating here since it was papa vito and it has seriously declined in quality since. ordered a few items about a week ago for my family, and the pizza was raw with toppings that had just been thrown on top (ordered a veggie pizza and the olives were cold, as if they were dumped out of a can). My husband…

Sara E.

Plum Tomato

Beware! I bought a plain slice and brought it back home. As I got ready to eat it I noticed little black dots thinking it might have been pepper or oregano but when I peeled the cheese it was rodent droppings. GROSS!

Carmen D.

Michelino’s Pizzeria

The sad part of this story is I had just left Staten Island, where I could have purchased a good pizza. I have only lived in Jersey a few years, and never tried Brooklyn Pizza, given its name I figured I would give it a shot. I went in and bought a pie, it was done in no time, which was my first suspicion…