Pizza in Scotch Plains, NJ

Fresh reviews:

Not sure why there are so many bad reviews. We go here on Sunday for pizza lunch after the kids finish up at the comic shop. Owners couldn’t be nicer! Pizza is delicious and prices are so fair! Get a whole pie (and it’s bigger than that huge silver tray) for like $ 11! They make you feel like family there. Love…

L L.

Maria’s Restaurant

I am giving this pizza joint (note that I use that term endearingly) two stars because although I only tried one item there, I don’t forsee myself going there again.I found myself there because the deli I had on my GPS apparently doesn’t exist. I look up at the overhead menu board to see what they have and the…

Brian And J.

Pizza Brothers of Scotch Plains

Nope! We just moved to the area and picked this as our first pizza place to try. We ordered a large pie with meatball topping on half of the pizza. The cheese was two different colors (topping side vs. plain side) and we quickly figured out why. This was obviously a pre-made, fully cooked plain pizza that was…

Kristen O.

Alfonso’s Pizzeria

Pizza and food are average at best but the service is HORRIBLE. The balding/bald kid behind the counter is always angry, often engaged in something way more important on his cell phone, and couldn’t string a friendly «may I help you» together to save his life. God forbid you have a question. I’ve seen him…