Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt in Wyckoff, NJ

Fresh reviews:

These guys serve Jane’s ice cream (small-batch ice cream made in the Hudson Valley– NOT factory-made like another reviewer said), and it is OUTSTANDING. My favorites are Milk Chocolate (the best chocolate ice cream I’ve ever had!) and Salty Caramel Pretzel. I also love the seasonal Currants and Cream flavor…

N. B.

Lulu’s Ice Cream and Chocolates

So I’ve been to Cherry Reds four times since they’ve opened. The first time, I wanted a milkshake and the owner was there and said they didn’t have the machine yet (they have a blender but whatever) and were super friendly and said they’d make me a milkshake the next time I stopped in. The second time, I wasn’t…