The 10 Best Pizza in Baldwin, NY

Fresh reviews:

My got to place for pizza! Whenever I’m in the mood for pizza I go here. Pizza is delicious (love the sesame seeds on the crust) and their pastas are great. I would highly recommend this place.

Katerine F.

Defrancisco’s Pizzeria

This used to be my go to pizza place. I guess they recently changed ownership. The people answering the phone struggle to understand my order, and have gotten it wrong the past 3 times. The food is not as good as it used to be. I guess I have to find a new place.

Rob H.

Amore Mio

OK. Here we go.We were lead to the Indian Restaurant across the road because it got awesome Unilocal reviews. The said restaurant was «closed due to construction» or some crap.This was on a Saturday night March 12, 2016 .Woe is me; I detest going out to eat on Long Island on Saturdays. I avoid the crowds at…

Kona K.

Gino’s Pasta & Pizza

Terrible… The pizza was like cardboard with cheese and sauce on it. Also had a chicken roll and the dough was raw. Plenty of other places to go to in the area. Definitely wouldn’t recommend it