The Top 10 Pizza in Bay Shore, NY

Fresh reviews:

Great friendly staff great food the prices are higher then most Italian spots but I never really gotten anything that wasn’t delicious there so it’s worth it to pay alittle extra plus I work next door so I see a lot of this place

Sarina G.

Buseto Pizzeria & Restaurant

Oh, how I wish The Pie at Salvatore’s was closer. I love coal fired pizza and The Pie at Salvatore’s is no exception. Just like Grimaldis, the family behind The Pie at Salvatore’s (and Salvatore’s Pizzeria in Port Washington) comes from NY Pizza Royalty — The Famous Patsy’s in NYC. These people know how to make…

Joe A.

The Pie at Salvatore’s

This place has some of the best food on Long Island! I’ve been coming here for over 20 years and the food has been consistent for all that time. Favorites are the Shrimp Scampi, Tortellini Mulberry and Rigatoni ala Vodka. And when in for dinner, don’t forget to ask for the zeppoli’s — they are some of the best…

Raven H.

Mulberry Street

We have been going to Joe’s for over 15 years, and it is consistently good, reliable authentic Italian food. The owners and staff are always friendly and the prices are reasonable. They stick to traditional offerings, so don’t expect anything trendy. Overall a great staple in the neighborhood — a good solid…

Bob K.

Joe’s Pasta & Pizza

If you like a pizza that will not give you heartburn later in the night, well you need to eat here. I love it! I want my pizza with lots toppings n not a lot of crust this was it. They support and deliver to all the local surrounding schools. Fantastic place with fantastic people

Nikki C.

Paul’s Pizza

If I could give this no stars I would. I ordered a Greek salad and got lettuce a whole red onion and parmasean cheese… what is that??? The calamari was bland and rubbery. never again! I will also be calling the manger about this disgusting food!