Bakeries in Brewster, NY

Fresh reviews:

If I lived closer, I would have returned some of the pastry I purchased on Sunday.I was so excited to see genuine lace cookies, but they were completely soggy– instead of light and crisp– the way they should be. They were actually overfilled with chocolate, so that the cookie portion was overwhelmed. The…

Susan R.

Brewster Pastry

This place is disgusting, don’t EVER eat the donuts. I knew a few people that worked here. They said when they came in at the beginning of the day, they used to pick out all the dead flies out of the oil and still use it. The owners are snobby wealthy people that don’t care about anyone, those ‘homemade’ pies…