The 10 Best Pizza in Brewster, NY

Fresh reviews:

Went here last night with my parents and grandmother. It was soooo good. The food, the atmosphere and our server were amazing. I can’t wait to go back. The scallops on their specials were so good, I can’t wait to have them again. The staff is so nice there. I would recommend going there!

Meg H.

Aversano’s Restaurant & Pizza

First, the only reason why I would give this 4 stars is because they’re the only pizzeria in the area that delivers otherwise I’d give them 3 stars.Expect the food to take about an hour to arrive and to also be cold. The food is pretty basic and all one note.If you’re hungry and can’t run out then this is your…

Kenneth T.

Brewster Square Pizza

Really solid pizza and wings :) service was friendly and their pizza and wing deal is a bargain. Crust is crispy and there’s a good sauce to cheese ratio. Wish we didn’t live in the opposite direction!

Michelle P.

Portofinos Pizza & Pasta

The food was ok. I had the chicken parmigiana and I couldn’t finish it all. And I didn’t take it to go. I knew I wasn’t going to eat it later on lol.

Griselda V.

Mezzaluna

Sinapi’s food is pretty good, but prices are rediculous. 10 garlic knots that ranged from the size of half the size of my fist, to the size of two quarters cost the same as two slices of pizza, plus I had a card so it was a 10 $ minimum, which was also completely insane. The only reason I actually bought…