The Top 10 Caterers in Ithaca, NY

Fresh reviews:

H&J was a great deal and very accommodating for a couple that wasn’t always the most organized and needed some guidance. Chelsea was extremely helpful crafting a menu and schedule for our wedding at the Farmers Market, keeping our costs in check and always gracious and responsive. All of our guests were…

Ted H.

H&J Hospitality

Nice function hall. One main room with a dance floor. I am here for a wedding. Looks like they have some ceiling decorations (not sure if they are with the venue or not. The staff is pleasant and organized.

Allison S.

Celebrations Banquet Facility, Inc

Serendipity recently did the catering for our wedding and the food was FABULOUS! We received so many compliments from our guests (we were a little busy and only managed to get tastes here and there) that we would whole heartily recommend them to anyone looking for a wedding caterer (Full Five Stars for food —…

Moria C.

Serendipity Catering

Recently renovated, tasty, good value, fresh fish fry. Unfortunately only open til 6pm weekdays, 7pm Fridays and closed Saturday and Sunday. The owner says he has a liquor license on the way and will soon be serving craft beers. Let’s hope they stay open later when that happens!

Tim M.

Cornerstore Party Rental

This food stand at the Ithaca farmers market has some very good salads, especially their vegan peanut noodle salad. This is my go to place when the cambodian food line is too long. I think the prices are a bit expensive for what you get, and some of the items are hit or miss, but overall I have not had a bad…

Matt H.

Macro Mama’s

I can’t tell you how dissappointed I was with this venue. We rented the hall for our end of the year gathering for our student group. The food was horrible and over priced, the management was extremely rude and the bar tender fed so many drinks to one of our underage members that we wound up having to get her a…

Leif E.

The Lakewatch Inn

12 places in Ithaca, ordered by rating:

H&J Hospitality

5.0

2 reviews

Telephone:	+1 607-882-9609
Address:	608 W Buffalo St

Caterers / Food

Celebrations Banquet Facility, Inc.

4.5

2 reviews

Telephone:	+1 607-539-7416
Address:	2331 Slaterville Rd

Venues & Event Spaces / Caterers

Serendipity Catering

4.5

2 reviews

Telephone:	+1 607-273-2145
Address:	950 Danby Rd

Caterers /

Cornerstore Party Rental

4.0

1 review

Telephone:	+1 607-273-5233
Address:	402 W Court St

Caterers /

Luna

3.1

20 reviews

Telephone:	+1 607-256-5862
Address:	310 Stewart Ave

American (New) / Food Delivery Services / Caterers

The Lakewatch Inn

3.0

2 reviews

Telephone:	+1 607-273-5253
Address:	1636 E Shore Dr

Party & Event Planning / Caterers

Macro Mama’s

3.0

1 review

Telephone:	+1 607-387-9111
Address:	Farmer's Market

Caterers /

Premiere Catering

···

Telephone:	+1 607-257-2055
Address:	213 Warren Rd

Caterers /

Kosher Dining Hall

···

Telephone:	+1 607-272-6907
Address:	106 West Ave

Caterers /

Tucker’s Catering

···

Telephone:	+1 607-273-2258
Address:	307 S Plain St

Caterers /

Bici-Cocina

···

Telephone:	+1 607-342-8173
Address:	Ithaca, NY 14850

Street Vendors / Colombian / Caterers

Ctb Appetizers

···

Telephone:	+1 607-257-2255
Address:	N Triphammer Rd

Caterers / Delis

The Top 10 Caterers

Ithaca, NY, United States

Fresh reviews:

12 places in Ithaca, ordered by rating: