Pizza in Mattituck, NY

Fresh reviews:

Stay away from this place. The pizza is pretty good to take out, but their pasta dishes are attrocious! I was informed that on wednesdays they have a discounted menu. So i decided to give them another shot. THEY WILL NOT TELL YOU ABOUT THE DISCOUNT MENU!!! So you have to be on the inside to know about this…

J E.

Michael Angelo Pizzaria

First off don’t sit in the pizzeria area unless you like eating pizza in a recording studio. The music is played on volume 10 and I could not have a conversation with my fiancée as a result. It was awkwardly loud. The food was acceptable for sustenance purposes only. My fiancée ordered a grandma slice that was…

Francisco L.

Michaelangelo of Mattituck

Revolting in every way.I’d driven by here a few times on road trips and was craving a slice of pizza. I should’ve turned around as soon as I walked in the door (and should’ve read the other 1-star reviews… d’oh!).I ordered a pepperoni slice and stupidly forked over $ 4 (really? more than in Manhattan?). Had…

Jane S.

Sicilian Pizza & Pasta

5 places in Mattituck, ordered by rating:

aMano Restaurant

3.9

20 reviews

Telephone:	+1 631-298-4800
Address:	13550 Main Rd

Michael Angelo Pizzaria

3.3

19 reviews

Telephone:	+1 631-298-4100
Address:	10095 Main Rd

Pizza /

Uncle Joe’s Pizza

3.0

5 reviews

Telephone:	+1 631-298-8910
Address:	13550 Main Rd

Pizza /

Michaelangelo of Mattituck

2.0

2 reviews

Telephone:	+1 631-298-4100
Address:	10095 Main Rd

Italian / Pizza

Sicilian Pizza & Pasta

1.1

9 reviews

Telephone:	+1 631-298-1947
Address:	55 Route 48

Pizza /

Pizza in nearby cities:

East Quogue

Hampton Bays

Westhampton Beach

Pizza

Mattituck, NY, United States

Fresh reviews:

5 places in Mattituck, ordered by rating:

Pizza in nearby cities: