The 20 Best Caterers in Middletown, NY

Fresh reviews:

Dis place is so good like tha pepperoni is delicious and the pizza deal on moday large pizza wit pepperoni 4 $ 8.00 is really worth it

Alejandro R.

Silver Lake Deli

My husband grew up in this area and always raved about their pizza. He did the ordering and ordered a shrimp scampi and shrimp and calamari fra dialo. It beat most pizzas I have had in NYC (and I have had a lot). The only issue is the grease on the shrimp scampi pizza. I assume the shrimp scampi pizza is just…

Clara W.

Caputo’s Pizzeria

Been here for years. Used to be really good! Lately the past few years they have rude staff, rude delivery guy and not so good food. The last 2 times I ate here Last year I got sick. I haven’t been back… Shame cause they used to have really good food.

Shawna M.

Brother Bruno’s Pizzeria & Restaurant

Completely over priced, the people are rude they talk to you as if your bothering them & the food was ok at most.

Ana R.

Salernos Deli & Bagels

Now renovated it’s called La Venizia. Dinner was late: 10:30 pm, music sucked. No cocktail hour for $ 125.00.will never go back and do not recommend it… Stay home. Leaving early!

Sandy R.

Brookside Manor

18 places in Middletown, ordered by rating:

The Fountains

5.0

1 review

Telephone:	+1 845-361-3287
Address:	40 Sands Rd

Caterers / Golf

Boston Market

4.0

6 reviews

Telephone:	+1 845-344-1817
Address:	400 Rt 211 E

Comfort Food / American (Traditional) / Caterers

Brother Bruno’s Pizzeria & Restaurant

3.8

14 reviews

Telephone:	+1 845-343-1550
Address:	124 Dolson Ave

Pizza / Caterers

Silver Lake Deli

4.0

4 reviews

Telephone:	+1 845-692-5255
Address:	599 Silvr Lk Sctchtwn Rd

Grocery / Caterers / Delis

Caputo’s Pizzeria

4.3

3 reviews

Telephone:	+1 845-342-1222
Address:	418 North St

Caterers / Pizza

Blueberry Mountain Ice Cream

4.1

10 reviews

Telephone:	+1 845-344-2500
Address:	655 Rt 17M

Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt / Caterers

Salernos Deli & Bagels

2.6

5 reviews

Telephone:	+1 845-692-7040
Address:	390 Crystal Run Rd

Caterers /

Brookside Manor

1.5

2 reviews

Telephone:	+1 845-692-4483
Address:	2257 Goshen Tpke

Caterers /

Brother Bruno’s

···

Telephone:	+1 845-343-1550
Address:	Dolson Ave

Pizza / Caterers

Kuhl Martin E

···

Telephone:	+1 845-343-8871
Address:	18 Courtland Pl

Caterers /

Townhouse Diner

···

Telephone:	+1 845-343-6080
Address:	229 Rt 211

Pizza / Caterers / Diners

Torres Deli & Groceries

···

Telephone:	+1 845-344-3312
Address:	8 Cottage St

Caterers / Delis

Empire Banquets & Catering - Holiday Inn

···

Telephone:	+1 845-692-4900
Address:	68 Crystal Run Rd

Caterers /

Tiffany’s Catering

···

Telephone:	+1 845-692-6900
Address:	68 Crystal Run Rd Holiday Inn

Caterers /

Brookside Manor

···

Telephone:	+1 845-692-4483
Address:	Goshen Tpke

Caterers /

Kuhl’s Highland House

···

Telephone:	+1 845-343-8871
Address:	512 Highland Ave Ext

Caterers /

Vellake’s Quality Meat & Deli

···

Telephone:	+1 845-342-6328
Address:	285 Route 211 W

Meat Shops / Caterers / Delis

TACO KING

···

Telephone:	+1 845-343-6811
Address:	79 Wickham Ave

Caterers / Mexican

Caterers in nearby cities:

Wallkill

The 20 Best Caterers

Middletown, NY, United States

Fresh reviews:

18 places in Middletown, ordered by rating:

Caterers in nearby cities: