The 10 Best American (New)

Montauk, NY, United States

Open map

Fresh reviews:

15 places in Montauk, ordered by rating:

La Fine
4.7
20 reviews
Telephone:
+1 631-483-5888
Address:
Montauk Manor 236 Edgemere St
American (New) / Italian
Muse @ the End
4.5
20 reviews
Telephone:
+1 631-238-5937
Address:
41 S Euclid Ave
American (New) /
668 The Gigshack
4.3
20 reviews
Telephone:
+1 631-668-2727
Address:
782 Main St
Music Venues / American (New) / Bars
Luigi’s Restaurant
4.0
2 reviews
Telephone:
+1 516-668-3212
Address:
4 S Euclid Ave
American (New) /
Swallow East Restaurant
4.2
20 reviews
Telephone:
+1 631-668-8344
Address:
474 W Lake Dr
American (New) /
The Saltbox
4.0
20 reviews
Telephone:
+1 631-238-5727
Address:
99 Carl Fisher Plz
Bars / American (New) / Seafood
The Crow’s Nest Inn & Restaurant
4.5
20 reviews
Telephone:
+1 631-668-2077
Address:
4 Old W Lake Dr
Hotels / American (New)
Surfside Inn Hotel
3.8
20 reviews
Telephone:
+1 631-668-5958
Address:
685 Old Montauk Hwy
American (New) / Hotels
Sole East Restaurant
3.3
17 reviews
Telephone:
+1 631-668-2105
Address:
90 Second House Rd
American (New) / Mediterranean
Navy Beach
3.8
20 reviews
Telephone:
+1 631-668-6868
Address:
16 Navy Rd
Seafood / American (New)
The Sloppy Tuna
2.6
20 reviews
Telephone:
+1 631-647-8000
Address:
148 S Emerson Ave
American (New) / Cocktail Bars / Music Venues
The Beach Club
3.0
2 reviews
Telephone:
+1 631-668-3200
Address:
290 Old Montauk Hwy
Resorts / American (New) / Seafood
Gulf Coast Kitchen
3.2
6 reviews
Telephone:
+1 631-668-3100
Address:
32 Star Island Rd
American (New) /
Tillies
3.1
7 reviews
Telephone:
+1 631-668-1729
Address:
290 Old Montauk Hwy
American (Traditional) / American (New) / Breakfast & Brunch
Harbor
2.6
20 reviews
Telephone:
+1 631-668-8260
Address:
440 W Lake Dr
Seafood / Lounges / American (New)

American (New) in nearby cities:

Groton