The 10 Best Pizza in Monticello, NY

Fresh reviews:

I’ve been emailed your Bonnie’s for close to 35 years and despite my proximally 10 year sabbatical from Monticello I tell you these boys have not missed a beat it’s probably one of the best sandwiches I’ve got to eat all over the world I grew up on the Godfather the roast beef which thank God is a rare which I…

Scott G.

Giovanni’s Subs & Pizzeria

Great little pizza place. We were not expecting the pizza to be as good as it was. The building is attached to another restaurant and ice cream parlor. It looks like the whole building is for sale. Hopefully if someone does buy it, they keep it the same.

Lee M.

Papa Luke’s Pizzeria

Moved from NYC to Sullivan County 3 years ago and have been looking for a good plain pizza. This place is close to Minitalia’s from Ridgewood NY so I will be coming back again.There are plenty of seats inside and the décor is unique. The booth we had had tape on the seat and the windows and shades could use a…

Amie M.

Brother Bruno’s Restaurant

I used to like this place. They burnt my pizza couple weeks ago. I let the women on the phone know. I didn’t ask for anything in return because I feel an establishment should offer something to make it right. No sweat. I had the cheesesteak today. The bread was not fresh. Guess I will give Brother Bruno a…

Power Face Y.

Colosseo Pizza Restaurant

Piss poor customer service they screwed up an order after waiting for over an hour, they don’t apologize and surely don’t want to keep your business

Melissa S.

Siena’s Pizza

12 places in Monticello, ordered by rating:

Papa Luke’s Pizzeria

4.8

6 reviews

Telephone:	+1 845-791-7272
Address:	42 Kitz Rd

Pizza /

Fialkoffs

5.0

2 reviews

Telephone:	+1 845-794-3420
Address:	250 E Broadway

Pizza /

Colosseo Pizza Restaurant

4.0

17 reviews

Telephone:	+1 845-791-1255
Address:	11 Raceway Rd

Pizza /

Giovanni’s Subs & Pizzeria

3.7

9 reviews

Telephone:	+1 845-794-8668
Address:	RR 42

Pizza / Sandwiches

Brother Bruno’s Restaurant

3.3

9 reviews

Telephone:	+1 845-791-4600
Address:	Route 42 North

Pizza / Italian

Siena’s Pizza

3.0

2 reviews

Telephone:	+1 845-791-7663
Address:	121 Broadway

Pizza /

Pizza Hut

2.3

3 reviews

Telephone:	+1 845-796-1616
Address:	352 E Broadway

Pizza / Italian / Chicken Wings

Toni’s Pizza and Trattoria

1.0

1 review

Telephone:	+1 845-707-4879
Address:	46 Forestburgh Rd

Pizza /

Roma Pizza Restaurant

···

Telephone:	+1 845-791-7662
Address:	121 Broadway

Pizza /

Kosher Pizza Plus

···

Telephone:	+1 845-794-4799
Address:	347 E Broadway

Pizza / Kosher

Albella Pizzeria Restaurant

···

Telephone:	+1 845-794-4117
Address:	46 Jefferson St

Pizza /

Kosher Pizza Monticello

···

Telephone:	+1 845-794-7499
Address:	347 E Broadway

Pizza /

Pizza in nearby cities:

Sparrow Bush

Port Jervis

The 10 Best Pizza

Monticello, NY, United States

Fresh reviews:

12 places in Monticello, ordered by rating:

Pizza in nearby cities: