Pizza in Olean, NY

Fresh reviews:

Good pizza and wings… I believe they changed the pizza shop to The Broken Wing. But I didn’t find any broken wings when I ate here.

Josh A.

Scooter’s

Again Napoli never fails to disappoint. Ordered a pizza and it was absolutely excellent. The cheese always blows my mind in how flavorful it is. The sauce squirts with every bite and the doughy crust is my go-to style of crust. Check out my previous review for a more in depth description of the Pizza. Since it…

Mitch N.

Napoli Pizza

$ 7 for a steak n cheese sub and its STEAK-UMS!!! Seriously!!!Should’ve went to subway in that case!!!Yep, been sick since I ate only half of that «sub»!How does this place have 4.5 stars???

Julie C.

Renna’s Pizza

People who live in Olean think this pizza is amazing but it’s cheaply made SMALL sliced pizza covered in grease. The sauce is made in a garbage can… seriously. you can watch them mix the sause in a garbage can… They charge $ 5.50 for four tiny slices of pizza and a drink that usually is 1⁄3 ice. There is a lot…