The Top 10 Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt in Orchard Park, NY

Fresh reviews:

I was down in OP and drove past Abbott’s Custard and decided to stop in based on a recommendation from a friend.The order was for a small pumpkin and a small chocolate almond. The ice cream was great and the serving size was pretty generous for a small. I would say it is superior to the Northtown favorite…

Pho S.

Abbott’s Frozen Custard

Not good at all! Just got a milkshake that literally is just milk:(I asked the girl working the window if that was indeed my order because it was so soup-like — not to mention it was spilling all over the cup. She said yes but said she would fix it. Okay, that’s fine… Had to wait a bit and when I got it back…

K V.

Route 20 Ice Cream

No longer open in a store front. We were in the area from out of state and were going to visit — but they are no longer open. They only do events now I guess. Unable to give a real review of the product, but bummed we couldn’t try it out– our kids were excited :(.