American (New) in Port Jefferson, NY

Fresh reviews:

Last night, my girlfriend and I spent the evening in Port Jeff and decided to dine at this lovely little location. The original Old Fields is in Greenlawn (and is quite small as we struck out one night trying to go there with the wait being well over an hour), but this one is a larger and more chic version of…

Josh G.

Old Fields

Been here a couple of times, and I’ve yet to be disappointed. Recently, my boyfriend and I came here on a beautiful Friday night. We live a town over from Port Jeff so we figured we’d come down for happy hour and grab a bite.On this particular night, parking was out of control– I’ve never seen PJ so packed. We…

Deanna Z.

Fifth Season Restaurant

had low expectations, but dinner was kind of terrible all around. it took almost an hour to get three very simple entrees. when they finally came, one of the orders was wrong. food quality was passable; however would avoid the ceviche if you have any respect whatsoever for the dish.waterfront dining in port…

James S.

Schafer’s

5 places in Port Jefferson, ordered by rating:

Old Fields

4.4

20 reviews

Telephone:	+1 631-331-9200
Address:	318 Wynn Ln

American (New) / Steakhouses / Burgers

Fifth Season Restaurant

4.4

31 reviews

Telephone:	+1 631-477-8500
Address:	34 E Broadway

American (New) /

Tommy’s Place

2.8

20 reviews

Telephone:	+1 631-473-8778
Address:	109 Main St

Pubs / American (New)

Schafer’s

2.6

20 reviews

Telephone:	+1 631-473-8300
Address:	111 W Broadway

Seafood / American (New) / Gluten-Free

American (New)

Port Jefferson, NY, United States

Fresh reviews:

5 places in Port Jefferson, ordered by rating: