Grocery in Sag Harbor, NY

Fresh reviews:

The only place I stop on my way to the beach. Great egg sandwiches (served all day long) and a wide array of deli sandwiches to choose from or just make your own. They also have an A+ butcher for when you want to throw together a last minute bbq with friends. Knocked off a star because it’s gets really crowded…

Molly O.

Cromer’s Country Market

I just paid $ 10 to get a smoothie that is disgusting. I’ve been here before and had a good smoothie, but I asked for a substitution because of an allergy (as I always do) and this person gave me a cup of Unblended kale water. I can’t even drink it because they did not take out the almond milk like I asked.I…

Kristen C.

Jimmy Jims Deli

Well over priced for what, moldy vegetables? There must be very little turn over in that store. Every summer the prices get higher, that I use to understand because of the summer people but when they went home the prices went back down for the locals. No more. The store is not clean, some people speak English…

Mary L.

Schiavoni’s Mkt

I don’t like this place. Was there this morning, bought a 5 oz juice for $ 8, and a coffee, and got the fish eye when I asked if there was soy milk for the coffee. Isn’t it a health food store? Then went to the front to pay and the guy at the register snapped at me when I failed to take my ticket after paying…

L R.

Provisions

6 places in Sag Harbor, ordered by rating:

Jimmy Jims Deli

3.8

8 reviews

Telephone:	+1 631-725-1930
Address:	3348 Noyac Rd

Grocery / Juice Bars & Smoothies / Delis

Schiavoni’s Mkt

3.7

9 reviews

Telephone:	+1 631-725-0366
Address:	Main

Grocery /

Cromer’s Country Market

3.4

20 reviews

Telephone:	+1 631-725-9004
Address:	3500 Noyac Rd

Grocery / Meat Shops / Delis

Provisions

3.5

20 reviews

Telephone:	+1 631-725-3636
Address:	7 Main St

Health Markets / Grocery

Whalebone General Store

···

Telephone:	+1 631-725-2277
Address:	3495 Noyac Rd

Grocery /

Cromers Southampton Wholesale Market

···

Telephone:	+1 631-725-9087
Address:	3500 Noyac Rd

Grocery /

Grocery in nearby cities:

Mattituck

Hampton Bays

East Hampton

Grocery

Sag Harbor, NY, United States

Fresh reviews:

6 places in Sag Harbor, ordered by rating:

Grocery in nearby cities: