Bed & Breakfast in Shelter Island, NY

Fresh reviews:

Quaint little B&B very close to a main street. Chris the hostess is very charming and friendly — full of tales to tell and very personable.Home is CLEAN, bed comfy and bathroom BRAND NEW. Shower pressure was great.No hot breakfast offered but was happy with the cereal and fresh coffee offered.Would be happy…

Dee C.

Two South Ferry B & B

My boyfriend and I just returned home from our stay at the Azalea house. We had a wonderful time! We visited shelter island to celebrate our anniversary, and the azalea house provided all the comfort and privacy we needed to have an amazing weekend. Thank you Añu!We chose the azalea house for the value (lowest…

Paula R.

Azalea House B&B

A very lovely clean bed and breakfast. Nice and friendly owner. My room was small but had everything we needed.

Renee C.

Candle Lite Inn & Guest House

Beautiful view and outdoor seating. Our mimosa and Bloody Mary wasn’t particularly flavorful. The duck confit was a bit dry and my poached eggs were sadly over poached. The lobster sandwich was decent and the waffle fries were delicious.