Seafood in Shelter Island, NY

Fresh reviews:

Seriously — what a breath of fresh air. Such a great experience at this place. Come here for no mess, no fuss, great seafood. I ordered the king crab legs dinner with a baked potato and coleslaw. Great food and great price. Totally family owned — they even put a bib on me! This will be a staple dinner stop…

Rachel W.

Bobs Restaurant

This is an interesting spot. It is very, very, very casual. The food is the real deal, the prep is questionable. There are basically two kitchens at this location. One is inside next to the seafood market where it appears that they have the usual suspects as far as a café. The next kitchen is located outside…

Michael O.

Commander Cody’s Seafood

Here is the summary of our experienceGreat view, good food, decent atmosphere, bad service.Here are the detailsThe location is lovely, right across the water. We were seated outside and so during dinner we were able to enjoy the sunset which was amazing. There were six of us for dinner and we all enjoyed our…