The 10 Best Bakeries in Tonawanda, NY

Fresh reviews:

Stopped in on St. Joseph’ Day and picked up a couple breads… anise and Italian. They had the traditional cross and cane shaped breads. The sign on their door indicates they don’t typically sell bread though. Lots of delicious looking cookies and pasteries!

Theresa R.

Romano’s Italian Bakery

excellent pastries and desserts. some wait staff are snarky, but…

Fridah l.

Romeo & Juliets Cafe

A new addition to the North Tonawanda Farmers Market is the cutely named SugarBox cupcake stand. This is their first year there and they don’t have a permanent spot yet, but they are worth looking for. It seems to be a mother daughter team working the booth. I heard there was a little baby at home too. Maybe…

Maria B.

SugarBox

I’m going to start by saying, shame on me. Even though they never get my order right, forget items from my order, and just simply can not accommodate a simple request like making bacon extra crispy, I still go back. NOT ANYMORE, GOOD BYE TIMMY HOEs. The last straw, I walk in and place my order (the only…