American (New) in Kelleys Island, OH

Fresh reviews:

Very disappointed in our dining experience here given the high ratings. Service was extremely slow. The restaurant refused to split checks for our group. The food was very underwhelming. We had a pork ragu dish that was extremely stingy with the meat and the pasta quality was poor. We also ordered a dish with a…

Sara P.

Kelley’s Island House

If you want to have a beer by the water go here. Not really any other reason. Service poor and food sub par. This place is for sale. The owners have given up on it. Too bad it used to be so nice.

Theresa G.

Dockers Waterfront Restaurant & Bar

3 places in Kelleys Island, ordered by rating:

Kelley’s Island House

4.3

20 reviews

Telephone:	+1 248-719-6362
Address:	131 Division St

American (New) / Bed & Breakfast / Lounges

Dockers Waterfront Restaurant & Bar

3.1

7 reviews

Telephone:	+1 419-746-2100
Address:	114 W Lakeshore Dr

Bars / American (New) / Seafood

American (New)

Kelleys Island, OH, United States

Fresh reviews:

3 places in Kelleys Island, ordered by rating: