The 20 Best Pizza in Mentor, OH

Fresh reviews:

I have used Maxim’s for cross country pasta nights for my kids, for a huge graduation party and most recently for my son’s wedding. The staff is friendly, accommodating and professional. The food is fresh and delicious and portioned nicely for catered events. I really appreciate these folks and would definitely…

Laurie G.

Maxim’s Pizza

Best pizza in the Mentor/Concord area. My family’s go to ordering spot. Owner is very personable will share stories of his life growing up in Italy

Justin S.

P & P’s Pizzeria New York Style

This has got to be one of my favorite pizza places. I live in fairport harbor and they actually deliver this far. Where other pizza places have jurisdictions and only go so far. This place is also open a bit later than others. Their pizza is delicious. I would definitely recommend this place to anyone.

Katie O.

Hungry Howie’s Pizza

Really yummy pizza. One of my favorite places to order from.And the owner is so friendly. Every time you see him he treats you like a long lost friend.The only complaint I have is that sometimes the crust is rather dry and tasteless.

Jessica C.

Calavittas Pizza Time

Used to eat here all the time. Loved it. Have moved out of state and was driving through on my way to see family. Got here 2.5 hours before close and they said they’re closing early.Maybe put a notice on your website or something next time.

Jody B.

Longo’s Pizza

Wow used to be my favorite place, had to ask for the rolls, the salad was less than in past visits, our waitress was slow but I was hungry. Ordered the chicken Marsala because it was alway good, well not no more I could have gotten drunk off it! Chicken was cooked but not the Marsala, it was poured out the…

John F.

Zappitelli’s Pizza

Ordered online (got a confirmation email) and waited more than two hours, and they never showed up. Tried calling them, and they were closed. Wrote to their corporate office, and didn’t even get a reply back. Definitely will not be ordering from them again.