The Top 10 Bakeries in Carlisle, PA

Fresh reviews:

Beemans did an amazing job on my sons 5th birthday cake! Kate took my idea and put it into cake form! Cake was amazing! Highly recommended!

Paula B.

Beeman’s Baked Goods

I have ordered 3 cakes from this bakery as well as stopped in on the fly for something fresh, all of which tasted amazing. I did have one issue with one of the cakes, but the owner was very accommodating to make up for it. And for that reason, I will return. Pricing is very reasonable. The red velvet cake is a…

Holly S.

Carlisle Bakery

Very slow service, but excellent food! Definitely recommend the pumpkin bagels with cream cheese! It was only like $ 1.99? :) So worth it.

Nikki S.

Courthouse Common Espresso Bar & Bistro

I popped in here needing to pick up a few things. I actually had to try and buy something so it wasn’t a wasted visit…THE GOOD…–prices seemed low, but they should be based on what they hadTHE BAD…–inside of store is very outdated–selection is pretty pitiful… no organic anything… lots of generic brands–seafood…

Jeff K.

Nell’s Shurfine Markets

This place is filthy and horrible service! I ordered a Oreo blizzard and then was handed my order with spoon covered with icecream. My friend ordered a buster bar and was told to get it out of the fridge herself. When I ate my icecream it didn’t taste good either. Maybe they need to clean their machines and…