The 20 Best Sandwiches in Carlisle, PA

Fresh reviews:

South side deli has great Turkey subs with cheese, I haven’t really ate here too much but the few times I went I was very impressed with the taste.

Dyla B.

South Side Deli

This is an upgrade of the dive it was. But still not a fine dining establishment. It has an ambitious menu but it doesn’t quite deliver. It has four star prices with two star food

John A.

Carriage house

Been here many times — on slow nights for dinner and a crazy Saturday night or two for drinks/dancing. Pretty good food/beer. Never have I ever felt as uncomfortable in a restaurant as I did on Wednesday, 12/23, 6 PM. Was a quiet night in the bar with only 4 people eating dinner and having drinks. 3 VERY…

Leah P.

Alibis Eatery & Spirits

I been coming to this restaurant for over 2 years now. Since I lived in keystone arms, it was really close to me. The first year I went there the food was really good. But for same reason it’s not good anymore. I went there 3 weeks ago and the subs didn’t taste the same. The guy making the good was eating as he…

Stephanie G.

American Heroes

Normally, I do enjoy Panera’s sandwiches. However, do NOT order online, especially not from this particular Panera. They claimed never to have received our order for a 13 sandwich + sides birthday lunch. We had a confirmation email about the order, yet it never arrived. Will not be trying to arrange our monthly…

Nicole S.

Panera Bread

21 places in Carlisle, ordered by rating:

Spoons Cafe

4.8

6 reviews

Telephone:	+1 717-793-1048
Address:	57 W Pomfret St

Salad / Soup / Sandwiches

Subway

4.5

2 reviews

Telephone:	+1 717-240-0045
Address:	299 Westminster Dr

Sandwiches / Fast Food

Domino’s Pizza

4.3

7 reviews

Telephone:	+1 717-249-1880
Address:	200 S Spring Garden St

Pizza / Chicken Wings / Sandwiches

South Side Deli

4.5

2 reviews

Telephone:	+1 717-960-0077
Address:	46 W High St

Delis / Sandwiches

Walnut Bottom Diner

4.1

20 reviews

Telephone:	+1 717-254-6867
Address:	936 Walnut Bottom Rd

Diners / Breakfast & Brunch / Sandwiches

Vinny Restaurant Pizza & Subs

4.2

17 reviews

Telephone:	+1 717-249-6417
Address:	330 S Hanover St

Pizza / Sandwiches

Carriage house

4.0

11 reviews

Telephone:	+1 717-323-0463
Address:	1582 Holly Pike

Burgers / Sandwiches

Miseno Risto Pub

3.3

9 reviews

Telephone:	+1 717-240-0133
Address:	598 W High St

Italian / Sandwiches / Pizza

American Heroes

3.6

14 reviews

Telephone:	+1 717-245-2472
Address:	872 Harrisburg Pike

Sandwiches / American (Traditional)

Panera Bread

3.2

12 reviews

Telephone:	+1 717-218-5023
Address:	40 Noble Blvd

Sandwiches / Salad / Soup

Alibis Eatery & Spirits

3.1

14 reviews

Telephone:	+1 717-462-4629
Address:	10 N Pitt St

Sandwiches / American (Traditional)

Subway

···

Telephone:	+1 717-245-9923
Address:	1180 Harrisburg Pike

Sandwiches / Fast Food

Cafe Cumberland

···

Telephone:	+1 717-245-3377
Address:	950 Soldiers Dr

Cafes / Soup / Sandwiches

Mama Bair’s Subs

···

Telephone:	+1 717-752-5924
Address:	1446 Holly Pike

Food Court / Food Stands / Sandwiches

Subway

···

Telephone:	+1 717-386-5577
Address:	Stonehedge Square Sh 950 Walnut Bottom Rd, Ste 15A

Sandwiches / Fast Food

Subway

···

Telephone:	+1 717-243-9455
Address:	40 Noble Blvd

Sandwiches / Fast Food

Careli’s Sub’s Pizza

···

Telephone:	+1 717-245-0043
Address:	931 Walnut Bottom Rd

Pizza / Sandwiches

Subway

···

Telephone:	+1 717-249-3199
Address:	46 W High St

Sandwiches / Fast Food

Subway

···

Telephone:	+1 717-249-3000
Address:	1257 Harrisburg Pike

Sandwiches / Fast Food

Blimpie’s Subs

···

Telephone:	+1 717-258-3181
Address:	712 Hanover Mnr

Sandwiches /

Camp Hill

The 20 Best Sandwiches

Carlisle, PA, United States

Fresh reviews:

21 places in Carlisle, ordered by rating:

Sandwiches in nearby cities: