The 10 Best American (Traditional) in New Castle, PA

Fresh reviews:

P.O. Lunch has the best hot dogs in New Castle. Be sure to get them with the world famous New Castle chilli! They also have the best grilled chicken sandwitch in town. This was not expected, I ordered the chicken sandwich on a whim one day and I was blown away! The chicken is so thick and juicy! This is sure a…

Will K.

PO lunch

Absolutely wonderful! Everything was homemade and delicious. Quick and friendly service, would definitely eat here again.

Josh H.

Hill House Restaurant

Unexpected find-turned out to be much better than I anticipated!Was in town for the weekend for an event, and this seemed to be the only option in town for a quick meal. Came with a friend and sat at the bar. Service was a little slow, but the bartender was very nice and fun to chat with, even if our drinks…

Kelsey W.

Starwood Restaurant & Pub

It had been over a dozen years since I last recall dining at a Ruby Tuesday. So long that I couldn’t remember what I had or even if it was any good or not. I don’t know you or how hungry you are, but you can do better than Ruby Tuesday. If you aren’t sure and give it a go, it’s just hard to imagine that you’ll…

Mark M.

Ruby Tuesday

I was there on a Friday evening during the dinner hour. I had heard positive things about their food and decided to give it a try.My first warning should have been as I watched them draw draft beers from the tap system with more foam than beer. My draft was cool, not cold and had a flat taste. I ordered the…