Papa John’s Pizza

First off, we love Papa John’s typically but we just moved and had this store in our area. The pizza was delivered timely by a friendly guy but the pizzas we ordered were not up to Papa Johns standard. We ordered a chicken bacon ranch pizza and my husband said it tasted like chicken on cardboard. The other peperoni pizzas were dry and over cooked. Our kids were starving so it got eaten mostly but then we called the customer service# and I talked to a man who said he could offer 10% instead of a new pizza so I asked if he could talk to the store and he did but I’m hoping it was an innocent disconnection but either way I had to call again. I was always very polite and kind bc that’s how I am but the new guy said the manager said no and I said thanks anyway. The customer service guys were nice and professional but we will never order from this store again just because it was so subpar and I’m being kind with that statement. If you’re in this area honestly pizza 73 is totally amazing compared to this store. I do realize that sometimes things aren’t perfect but to not even send a replacement pizza, was not a good sign regarding this store. (We have a whole uneaten pizza left)

This location doesn’t seem capable of delivering pizza on time. We’ve ordered from them several times for work functions that start at a specific time and not once have they delivered our pizza when we’ve asked for it. Once it was as much as 1.25 hours late. They seem to care very little for other people’s schedules. The pizza’s good but this was the last time I’ll be ordering from them. If only we could trust this company to deliver on what they promise.
UPDATE: They didn’t deliver our pizza at all. They called a half an hour after our pizza was supposed to be delivered and said their driver never showed up, so we’ve got a boardroom full of people and no food. DO NOT ORDER FROM HERE.

This place gets an automatic 3 starts for not being a Pizza 73.
Having avowed never to willingly consume the cardboard monstrosities being passed off as pizzas from that oddly numbered establishment ever again, I opted for a «John’s Favorite» from good ol’ PJ’s.
Delivery time was adequate. Pizza arrived hot. So far, so good.
It was pretty good — much better crust — the added bonus of a little packet of garlic butter for me to toss in my gullet and a jalapeño that I always eat directly in front of any women present so they know just how manly and no-​care ever I really am.
Papa John’s isn’t the best pizza out there, but as far as delivery goes it’s a pretty safe bet. Way above pizza hut, miles above Pizza 73 — but its no Atlas or Coco Brooks.
3.5 stars.