Cocelli Pizza

Great wings… barbeque are really good… Pizza was great! Also ready for pickup when asked for

This is my new favourite pizza place in Newmarket! The pizza is perfect every time. The garlic bread is sooo good and I almost always order it with my pizza. Their staff and service is friendly and fast. My only minor complaint is that I do wish that they would put a piece of parchment paper in between their garlic bread with cheese so that the cheese does not end up on one side of the bread.

The stars don’t lie, I’m a fan! This is my families new go-​to pizza place. Whether we walk-​in, order pick-​up or get delivery, it’s always hot and crispy. Different to other places, they don’t skimp out on toppings and have a great, unique sauce!
My one complaint: they are Italian and don’t speak English very well, so ordering over the phone has proven tricky. We try to do half-​toppings every now and then because I’m the only one who likes pineapple and so far 50% of the half-​and-​half order have been completely wrong. The only good thing about those mistakes was that we got more toppings than we paid for and that we all liked.
Yesterday we got their wings for the first time. SO GOOD. Not the biggest, but definitely in competition with local wing places like sneakers and tom & jerry for size. Above all they were really well cooked. They were lightly battered and fired with the sauce served on the side (for delivery). Which means they were crispy once we put the sauce on. They also gave so much sauce and they were finger-​licking good! Will definitely get the wings again.

Great Pizza and fantastic service!
Was running through the plaza on route to an appointment and thought I would give this new spot a try. Happy I did.
Probably the freshest pizza crust and ingredients I’ve had in a long time.
Has a great family run feel to it as well.
CREDIT CARD worked fine for me.
It’s not a fancy sit down restaurant, but is a pizzeria I will definitely try again. Will probably also try their delivery.

If I could give this place zero stars, I think I would. This place is brand new and I understand that there are bound to be some adjustment issues or growing pains. I understand if you can’t accept debit or credit as payment methods yet. But it would have been better to know that before placing my order. Because there was no nearby branch of my bank, my order was $ 3 more expensive than it should have been. The pizza toppings were not distributed correctly (on the whole pie instead of only on half, and under the cheese instead of on top, as we had requested). The «crispy» crust was as limp as a cooked noodle, and the overall taste was oddly salty.
I can only hope that in the future the experience improves, but I’ll never need to know, because that’s the last time I’ll visit this place.