Allan’s Pastry Shop

The Best patty I have ever had, and I have had a lot especially back in the high school days this was a great snack.
the crust is buttery soft and a lightly crisp (if you buy the packs to bring home, don’t over heat it, max 15mins at 350 in the mini oven) have one or 2 fresh from the store, it’s soo good you will finish it in a minute, it just melts in your mouth.
the mild beef and spicy beef is really good and also the curry goat! yum. the only thing is that i wish there was more filling. I don’t mind if i have to pay more if there is more filling inside. the price is very very reasonable!

Excellent patties!!! I get then cocktail size when we’re having functions. The white rum cakes are out of this world.

Best patties in the GTA… HANDS DOWN!!! And always friendly and prompt customer service!

It’s been around for years. I didn’t even know it existed until my friend brought me here. It’s a hidden gem, surrounded by big competition like McDonalds, Popeye’s and PizzaPizza. Every very time I eat no name patties from a supermarket, I’m sad that it’s not from here. It has changed my life. It’s so cheap and the amount they prepare for a day is amazing.
When you take a bite of the patty, it’s so flaky. The juices that you see and the amount of meat inside is just right. All the flavours are great. I have tried every single one of them and prefer goat the most.
The owner is nice and friendly, always with a smile and so happy to customers. My friend and I would always order and walk around while eating it only to circle back for another one with the owner always smiles and saying ’ you again?’ The store has an amazing aroma that you can smell throughout the plaza and outside.

This review is specifically for their cocktail patties. The other review I wrote still applies.
Got the cocktail patties, thinking my youth group kids would be in for a treat, given how amazing their regular-​sized patties are. Well, the cocktail patties have the exact same pastry as the regular ones do. They’re flaky and fragrant and absolutely mouthwatering. The filling is where they lost three stars. Why so drastic? Well, there was next to no filling. So these cocktail patties were about the size of a large samosa. I cracked one open after reheating it and found less than a teaspoon of filling… and most of that was sauce. I found maybe five small bits of ground beef. Um, yeah. Massive problem with that. That makes me really upset. Won’t be buying those again…
But I’ll still return for the regular-​sized patties.

These patties are pretty good and different from what I have previously tried. I can see why everyone really likes this place… I believe what shines the most about their patties is their pastry. It is different compared to other Jamaican patties in this respect, but I don’t know if I like the pastry as much the traditional ones. These ones are not bright yellow, perhaps they don’t use tumeric powder. What’s also interesting is that their patties look thicker than most patties sold elsewhere. That is mostly due to the pastry being super fluffy/​flakey, not exactly stuffed with a lot of filling.
My first impression of their patty is that it was very fluffy, and flakey, smelled great. The pastry is slightly sweet as well. It reminds me more of a pie crust. I’ve tried the spicy beef and the chicken versions. They also have mild beef version. Prices are very reasonable, I believe I got a box of 12 patties for about $ 11 – 12?

PROPER. ALLAN YOU MY MAN.
I haven’t had Jamaican patties since elementary school so when I friend asked if I was game for the patties, there was a lot of jumping up and down and unintelligible loud noises.
We raced to the plaza and ordered two each (less than $ 2 each) and I have to say these were KILLER. Fluffy, flaky, warm pastries filled with tender meat! There’s beef patties (mild, medium, spicy), curried goat, chicken, and one other I’m forgetting. Super affordable and appropriate for any time and occasion.
I only gave it a 4.5÷5 because I wish there was more meat in the patty. Just a teensy bit more and… Bliss.

In this rundown part of town, in this rundown plaza you will find this gem. I kid you not when I confess that these are probably the best patties I have ever had in Toronto. Forget Tastee’s, Geroge’s…or whatever patty shops you’ve been to. This is the ONLY place that does patty righteousness. I am no patty connoisseur and I probably don’t know what an authentic patty should be like but I would say 90% of the patties I have had in Toronto tastes like frozen patties that have been sitting under the heat lamp for the past 2 and a half weeks.
The patties here are moist, juicy (yes, this is a bold claim but it’s true), tender and flaky. So go ahead, knock back at least 3 of these, they are less than a buck each.
This place closes early (6pm?) so visit early and visit often.

I believe these are the best patties I’ve ever tried. I’ve brought these into work and they all seem to agree.
Soft flakey crumbly pastry surrounding the saucy delicious filling.
Chicken, beef & goat options.

CLEARLY superior to Patty King, etc. Allan’s patties are truly excellent and addictive, especially the spicy beef (I was underwhelmed by the less-​flavourful goat, personally) and are the best I have found in T.O. (with Mr. Jerk on Wellesley running a close 2^nd).
This patty is the saucy variety, with the meat pulverized to a spicy paste, and no discernible meat chunks or ground beef texture, as expected, encased in a smooth, tender outer dough. I am personally still looking for the nostalgia patty that shows off a truly flaky, layered puff-​pastry-​like shell, like the Terrace-​Brae patties of my childhood, but these are absolutely top-​notch! I LOVE ‘em!
NOTE: Store is hidden INSIDE the tiny mall at the peanut plaza, (yes there is a tiny mall inside) with no indication outside or on any signage.

Allan’s sells the regular size and miniature, «cocktail» size in frozen format, but only regular sized patties are available ready-​to-​go.
I was so excited that I bought a pack of 12 frozen spicy beef patties, plus a warmed up goat and beef patty to eat on the spot/​standing outside of the neighbouring Dollarama, because I’m just classy like that.
These patties have a fluffy, slightly sweet outer pastry that envelopes a few tablespoons of filling. Though even at its maximum spiciness level, registers at a mild to me. Like, seriously mild. What Thai places call «Caucasian-​people mild». T’was OK. After seeing Allan’s rank relatively high on many patty reviews and «best of» lists, I was expecting a brain-​splosion of awesome beefy goodness, but I felt there just wasn’t enough filling for the outside to inside ratio. Considering they work out to a mere $ 1.17 cost per frozen patty though, I can’t exactly complain (one box of 12 frozen, regular sized patties will set you back $ 14)…but I sure do wish there was more filling!

How do you review a nostalgia?
Back in high school, I used to hang out at the rink south of Peanut Plaza with the hockey kids from the nearby high school. Every time we got a break, we would go to Allan’s or Mr. Jerk at Peanut Plaza for cheap food.
It never came across my mind to eat patty again after I went to university. I’m glad this pastry shop is still around and the patty was still as good. I can’t decide if Allan’s or George’s Tastee has better Jamaican patty (I went to Tastee A LOT when I was in junior high). If you ever come to Allan’s, make sure you get a patty with a toasty coco bread. The soft and flaky texture is truly addictive.

Came here based on the reviews from other Unilocalers. Arrived at 7 pm on a Friday and they close at 8. There were no hot patties available. No offer to heat one up. Just not available. So I ordered 12 patties in a box, veggie, chicken, curry goat, an spicy beef. Bought some coco bread and some spiced bun. Got home and put some patties in the oven. I can honestly say I was thoroughly disapponted. There is next to no filling in these patties and barely flavoured. The spicy beef was not spicy, and yet vegetable patty had barely any veggies. The coco bread was nice and soft and I have no issue with the crust on the patty, I just can’t believe they only put gravy on the inside of their patties. It is mostly crust. I was very disappointed with my experience. I wouldn’t return and won’t recommend.

This is the only place in the GTHA to get some proper and authentic (spicy beef) Jamaican patties. If you’re not keen on the beef, there are many more options including but not limited to goat, vegetarian, etc. Even if it is slightly out of the way, be sure to grab some patties for the road!

Went here today for the first time, and was excited given the glowing reviews.
I’d say it was fine, but I wasn’t as blown away as others. Being touted as the best patty ever and all that, maybe it set the bar too high. I enjoyed it, though. The crust was flaky and nice, and the fillings had good flavour.
First I got a curry goat patty, since I’d never had a jamaican patty with goat in it. I thought it was interesting and definitely brought something new to the table. It was spicier than I expected, and overall satisfying.
Then after some shopping nearby, I went back and ordered combo 2. I got a mild beef patty, a coco bun, and a peanut punch ($ 2.75). The value was good. I liked the softness of their coco bun, but I felt it didn’t add much to the equation. I live quite close to Allwyn’s (another well known jamaican patty institution) and I don’t think Allan’s did enough for me to warrant the trip, at least not often.
If anything, the big omission was coleslaw. My favourite item to get at Allwyn’s is a «patty on a bun with slaw»… he puts the patty in the bun for you, then throws in a nice helping of delicious coleslaw. It pairs so well. In my eyes, the slaw is the star of the meal, and it’s what elevates it from good to great. To me, that’s the point of the coco bun — to act as a housing so the coleslaw doesn’t go anywhere. Having just gotten the patty and a bun today, it felt empty — the patty is already wrapped in its own high-​carb breading… what’s the point of wrapping it in even more empty filler? Essentially, it was missing that satisfying creamy yet crunchy slaw I love so dear.
Would I go back? I would, if only because of the extra variety. Allwyn’s generally only has mild and spicy beef, and rarely has chicken/​veggie. Allan’s seems to keep all 5 on hand at all times. The goat was worth it since it’s unique and has a nice taste.
If I went back, I’d get just patties on their own (either fresh or a dozen to go) but I don’t see myself making a trip to Peanut Plaza just for this. Overall, I found it good enough to get 4 stars.
P. S. Service was fast and quite friendly. Cash only.

Probably the best Patty you’ll have in Toronto.
You can pretty much read the other reviews and they’ll all tell you the same thing. Allan’s Pastry Shop is this small little place that doesn’t even try to grab your attention. They’ve got people rushing in and out just to get boxes of their patties and coco bread. You know a place is damn good at patties when their entire menu is 4 different kinds of patties and coco bread…
They have mild/​spicy beef, chicken, vegetarian, and curry goat patties for those who were curious. I tried the mild beef and chicken ones which I loved! The thing that separates these patties from the others is definitely the flakiness of the patties. They’re actually layered and are so soft and warm that you just want to peel the layers between and snuggle in…
The fillings are wet and juicy… but in a good way? The filling basically looked as though they were actual meat at one point instead of having been a paste their entire life. Not dry at all and when simmering in that bread… damn…it’s a good patty.
Buy them in boxes for $ 11 or each at $ 1.19 each. The boxes are probably worth it, but I wouldn’t be able to justify to my gut why I brought home a box of these heavenly patties…

Best Patties in town, actually, and not just my opinion. It’s practically famous, like one of those places that whoever knows about it knows it’s the best.
They sell Chicken, Beef, Vegetable, and Goat patties. Personally I like the Goat Patties the best.
You can buy em hot and fresh, or frozen to take home. The frozen ones come in two sizes, regular and mini; the mini patties are great for parties.

I’ve been eating Allan’s since the late 70’s when they had a retail outlet on Montezuma trail in Agincourt. They are hands down «the best» patties you can buy in the GTA and I would wager to say in the country – yes they are that good. They are even superior to the patties you can find in Jamaica. They have remained pretty consistent over the years – the pastry recipe has changed slightly as it is more lighter and puffier than it was in the 80’s and 90’s. I’ve tried all the flavors but prefer spicy beef.

…me collarbone ! … me arm this is fantastic… …
I echo what most have said …
I had lunch at Allan’s at the Peanut Plaza almost every day and never got sick of it.
The BEST «patties»
Back in the 80s, when I was in junior high and high school, we ate patties on coco buns for lunch at Allan’s at the Peanut Plaza almost every day and never got sick of it.
Throughout the years, I’ve tried many different patties (Randy’s, Michidean’s, Patty King, etc.) but Allan’s still reigns supreme! I think what sets them apart from the other patties is the soft, flaky crust and the abundance of meat in the patties. The filling is spiced just right and perfect when it drips on to the soft coco bun.
All my friends and I live out in the East end now but every one of us still takes a road trip up to Allan’s when we’re craving patties.

Fresh, hot and tasty! oh and Cheap! For a dozen it‘s about $ 12 (around there) and every penny is worth it.
I was never a fan of beef patties as it reminds me of high school years when these frozen ‘tummy fillers‘always end up upsetting the tummy itself. Basking in its glory under the heat lamps caught the eyes of students too cool to be concerned over nutrition value.
These yellow bad boys with heavenly fillings of beef, chicken, curry goat with the choice of purchasing it spicy is an exception !!! I‘ve been to the best Jamaican restos located on Lawrence and Allan‘s patties are through the roof with the quality factor!
Plaza is crap, yes but this place makes the annoying, always-​full parking lot easier to deal with. The freshness never seems to fade even after a couple of days. I just pop one in the oven and VOILA!!! It‘s a great way to curb my hunger as I prepare dinner for my family. Takes the taste-​testing down a notch.