The sesame seed crust blew my mind. Solid pizza, slightly abrupt, slightly off putting person who answered the phone, but going by other reviews that’s kind of the norm. Reasonably priced and pretty tasty. I’d absolutely order again, only for that crust!
Sylvia D.
Place rating: 5 Abbotsford, Canada
I see why it’s called Fat Tony’s, if I worked there too I would be fat too! Probably the best pizza I’ve ever had!!!
Nick V.
Place rating: 4 Whistler, Canada
This is the cheapest by the slice pizza in Whistler. Not the best pizza by the slice in my opinion but for $ 2 when you need something filling quickly this is a great option. Cheap lunch if your short on cash or time. The service is lack luster, but it’s a pizza place with younger party going servers who are usually hung over from the party the night before. I wouldn’t go there for anything but a quick cheap slice if I’m in a hurry or maybe after a night of partying because they are open until 3am.
Cole T.
Place rating: 1 Southeast Calgary, Canada
Awful, they lady didn’t care about her job and seemed to hate being there. I would too. The pizza was also bad and not up to par. But at least is was cheap
Mike S.
Place rating: 1 Penn Valley, CA
Only takes cash. But insists on 1 – 1 conversion rate if paying in US dollars. Indoor music too loud — offensive rap lyrics ‘fing muther feffer’ Not kid friendly.
Michael T.
Place rating: 4 San Diego, CA
Awesome thick crust pizza. Great sauce and cheese — best pizza in Whistler. 4 instead of 5 for the bad attitude chick behind the counter. You’re serving pizza not shoveling asphalt — lighten up :)
Liam H.
Place rating: 5 Downtown, Las Vegas, NV
Great way to end the day with cheap pizza. It’s not fancy but it’s good value. Great after a day of skiing
Chris V.
Place rating: 1 Los Angeles, CA
Horrible pizza, not as horrible as when the ottoman turks tried to attempt genocide on the Armenians, but up there. the owner was rude when i was up there after a long day of snowboarding, all i wanted was a slice of pizza
Kirstie V.
Place rating: 1 Downtown, Vancouver, Canada
Horrible. Asked for cheese pizza and told me I could only have cheese and mushroom because they didn’t want to make any more. Allergies to mushrooms and didn’t seem to care. Fairly annoying.
Kristi N.
Place rating: 5 Vancouver, Canada
We were craving pizza during our visit to Whistler. Fat Tony’s selection was the best on their website so we called them. A nice guy answered and happily customized our order. The same guy arrived quickly to our hotel and was very pleasant. The pizza itself was so good! Loaded with fresh toppings right to the amazing sesame crust. Can’t wait to eat leftovers this morning. No wonder Tony is Fat. 100% recommend!
Neal E.
Place rating: 4 Haymarket, VA
There are two Fat Tony’s locations in Whistler Village — this one is in between 2 Guys and a Pipe and Stonesedge Kitchen. There is no interior seating here. Been to Fat Tony’s twice for an after midnight pizza snack after drinking our way through the Village. I’ve tried the Ham and Pineapple, the Pepperoni, and the Blue Cheese and meat. All were tasty and hit the spot! Both times I’ve been there — there was quite a few folks in line who also needed a snack after drinking!
Heather M.
Place rating: 4 Olympia, WA
Not sure why this place doesn’t have a higher rating?! The pizza is cheap, tasty, and they have a pretty good variety. I personally liked the blue cheese and meat. It was delicious!
Jeremiah F.
Place rating: 4 Grand Junction, CO
Had a yummy $ 2 slice of sausage and pepperoni with BBQ sauce. Guy was friendly and let me pay with US$ crispy and tasty.
Samantha D.
Place rating: 1 Roseville, CA
Not friendly at all and pizza was mediocre at best.
Omar S.
Place rating: 1 Seattle, WA
Let’s see. Beer on menu, but liquor license expired. Hmm. Place looks like it’s never been cleaned. Tables are so wobbly you can’t sit without food shifting around. If you look down at the floor you’d wish you hadn’t. Pizza crust lathered in sesame seeds. What? I’ll admit that’s a first. Will never come here again. Must be a take out place.
Lala B.
Place rating: 5 Los Angeles, CA
This is the best pizza in Whistler. I fell in love once I walked past the store and the smell lured me in. From that moment on I knew this was the only pizza place for me here in Whistler. I will post pictures when I order!
Kevin W.
Place rating: 4 Vernon, Canada
Ordered a chicken bacon ranch, this was quite a delicious pizza good dough, good cheese lots of toppings. The sauce was a bit heavy on herbs but otherwise great! I would highly suggest this pizza place. Pizza was 23 $ which I figured was a bit high, but the. When it arrived it was huge, and delicious.
Joshua J.
Place rating: 1 London, United Kingdom
Soggy crappy dough, shitty cheese ‘product’, cold, rude reception, not many more words worth writing aside from the fact that I threw my entire pizza away in the trash uneaten(bar the few bites I took and spit out). The worst pizza I’ve had in my entire life. Called to inform staff how bad it was, dude didn’t give a toss.
Dan W.
Place rating: 3 Ridgewood, NJ
I’m gonna set it straight because I know what good pizza is and I am tired of traveling to far away places and seeing Unilocal reviews of «oh great pizza» or «solid ‘za brooo». This place is glorified dominos pizza and dont get me wrong I do love a little dominios(pronounced duh-mini-oze) but it really isnt pizza it is its own genre. I will say though that this place is better than dominos. Delivery was fast they said 45 min but actually showed up in half an hour which is a plus. I got the famed beef and blue cheese pizza which is ok I will give it 3 stars. The real prize here is the chicken bacon ranch which was excellent for what it was a hard 4 stars. You would think that would average out to 3.5 stars, but I would be doing solid pizza establishments all over the world an injustice if I gave this place 4 stars. BOTTOMLINE: If you are vacationing in whistler and feel the need to get pizza delivery this is a safe, satisfying bet.
Rob W.
Place rating: 4 Torrance, CA
We only ordered in. I’m not a huge fan of ‘za, but had to try th emeat lovers pizza, which was pretty good. Ton of meat as advertised. I had the wings, which were pretty good. Decent amount of spice. Also had the caesar salad, which was fine.