Piero’s offers a variety of dishes, some traditional, some with an Americanized spin, all at fair prices. We have eaten here on several occasions and have always been fairly satisfied. People have been leaving poor reviews about this place– just keep in mind, it’s a glorified pizza palace. You want pizza? You want finger foods? Interested in Americanized Italian food, welcome to Piero’s. We come here every so often, with literally zero expectations of this place bring anything more than just another pizza shop. And it honestly doesn’t disappoint.
Kayla M.
Place rating: 1 Akron, PA
The last time we were there we stopped in on a Friday night for a beer. We were disgusted to see the owner smoking a cigar behind the bar as he and his friends were playing card games. I thought this was a nonsmoking restaurant?! This just adds to the terrible food and mediocre service!
Kesha G.
Place rating: 1 Ephrata Township, PA
I have NEVER had such a terrible experience at a restaurant before. We’ve been going to this establishment for years, however we will not be returning. We ordered seafood pasta and the pasta looked like a child’s portion, 2 of the clams didn’t open and ¾ of the few pieces of lettuce they called a salad were rotten. Who pays $ 2.99 for a rotten salad? The platter tonight wasn’t worth $ 18.99 either. Our server didn’t ask if we wanted refills nor if our food was ok. When we told her about the clams, she blamed the cook and never offered to make things right. When we said something at the register, they too blamed the cook and refused to do anything. Maybe if the cook turned off his phone and stopped texting, our food and service would have been better. The lobster bisque was good, but had(1) ¼″ piece of lobster for $ 7 a bowl. Way overpriced if you ask me.
Carlos D.
Place rating: 1 Harrisburg, PA
I came there with a buddy of mine during dinner time on a saturday. It was dead. There were perhaps 20 people in the building. We waited 15 minutes to place our order and no one even acknowledged our existence. So we left.
Sara P.
Place rating: 4 Leola, PA
Just ate here for the first time, we got take out. We both got cheese steaks. They were actually quite good. One of the only ones we’ve enjoyed in the area. We also both got a slices, plain and buffalo chicken. They both were not good. This is the second time a pizza place in this area put the chicken and buffalo sauce on top of a plain slice and called it buffalo chicken. Just so you know that’s not how it’s done and it doesn’t taste good. We’ll definitely do cheese steaks again and explore other things on the menu.
Laura W.
Place rating: 2 Chelsea, Manhattan, NY
Horrible Italian food(stuffed shells and lasagna). Appetizers were good enough(fries, wings, mozzarella sticks) except the stuffed mushrooms were cold. Moral: visit if you’d like finger foods — not a meal.
Ted T.
Place rating: 2 Richland, PA
Not at all when an Italian restaurant should be. Want a difference sauce on your pasta forget it they will not do it. Most of the food is average although they do have some dishes that are a bit better than most. The attitude of the owner and the waitstaff is what really takes this restaurant way down. It is sad because they could be an excellent restaurant with just a bit of effort care and passion
Brian O.
Place rating: 4 Las Cruces, NM
Dinner at Piero’s this evening. We shared a Stormboli and a steak sub. They were both very good. The stromboli filling of ham, salami, pepperoni, and cheese was sufficient and the dough was very good. Plenty of tomato sauce served with it. The steak sub was served with plenty of marinara sauce too. Friendly service.