Wiseguys Pizzeria & Pub

Appleton, United States

4.3

Open now

12 reviews

Accepts Credit Cards

Contacts

QR code, vCard

Telephone:
+1 920-830-8336
Website:
www.wiseguysappleton.com
Address:
1440 Oneida St Ste J, Appleton, WI, 54915
Nearby public transportation stops & stations:
2.4 miAppleton Bus Terminal
Categories:
QR code
Download QR Image Download vCard

Map

Streetview

Activate map

Bussiness info

Accepts Credit Cards
Yes
Good for Groups
Yes
Attire
Casual
Alcohol
Full Bar
Has TV
Yes

Today

Today 4:00 pm – 10:00 pm
Open now
Local time (Appleton) 8:27 PM Wednesday, May 28, 2025

Business hours

Monday –
Tuesday 4:00 pm – 9:00 pm
Wednesday 4:00 pm – 10:00 pm
Thursday 4:00 pm – 10:00 pm
Friday 4:00 pm – 11:00 pm
Saturday 4:00 pm – 11:00 pm
Sunday 4:00 pm – 9:00 pm

Related places

Explore similar places:
1
mi
Sabre Lanes
1330 Midway Rd
1
mi
Italia Pizza & Pasta
2303 S Oneida St
1.1
mi
Little Caesars Pizza
317 E Calumet St
1.8
mi
Fratellos Waterfront Restaurant
501 W Water St
2.3
mi
Topper’s Pizza
109 E College Ave
2.3
mi
Sal’s Pizza
411 W College Ave

Vicinity

Near this location:
50
ft
Press Start Games
1440 Oneida St
290
ft
Van Zeeland’s Auto Care Centers
1370 Oneida St
340
ft
Gunderson Cleaners
1440 S Oneida St
340
ft
skinSPArations LLC
1440 S Oneida St
360
ft
Van Zeeland’s Auto Care Centers
1370 Oneida Rd
750
ft
Soothing Touch Massage & Bodywork
1981 Midway Rd Ste C

12 reviews of Wiseguys Pizzeria & Pub

No registration required
Place rating: 5
Onalaska, WI
Best pizza in town. Hands down. Sauce is amazing. We also had the eggplant appetizer… Which is also fantastic.
Place rating: 5
Sedalia, MO
This is a great place. The deep dish Capone is my favorite along with the onion rings. The staff are awesome and if you go a little later for dinner there is always no wait for a table. I’d put this pizza against Gino’s or UNOs in downtown Chicago.
Place rating: 3
Appleton, WI
Excellent food, never had anything we didn’t love here. But Brittany is terrible and has a bad attitude. We always consider going somewhere else when Brittany is working.
Place rating: 3
Menasha, WI
The BEST thin crust pizza in the valley! Seriously, you’re missing out if you have not at least tried this place. Plus, they always have some pretty decent beers on tap. The rub however, is the service. I’ve actually taken to calling ahead and getting our pizza to go because the service has been so consistently frustrating. The prices seem a tad high to me, but the pizza is worth it. It is with trepidation (the service) that I recommend giving Wiseguys a try if you’re looking to expand your pizza horizons.
Place rating: 5
Appleton, WI
Very nice restaurant! Food was delish, service was fast and courteous. We ordered the onion rings (more like onion strings) and the coco thin crust pizza. We will be back with our friends.
Place rating: 2
Menasha, WI
Went here with my husband for a quiet dinner. Walked inside and was ignored by the bartender for about 6 minutes despite standing at the bar (she was more interested in talking with the 5 or so drunk locals at the far end of the bar). Radio was super loud– to the point you can’t talk to the person next to you. I could understand this on a game-​day but this was ridiculous. The food we had was soaked in grease and seemed to not even be strained before being served. I would never eat at this place again. We have had success in ordering their pizza and having it been serviceable.
Place rating: 5
Menasha, WI
I love going to Wiseguys! Great little place more people need to know about! Good service, nice atmosphere and decent prices. Love love love the Coco pizza. It’s amazing. May be the best pizza I’ve ever had.
Place rating: 5
Appleton, WI
The service is excellent. The atmosphere is casual and very welcoming. The pizza and pasta is very good. And to top it off the beer selection is good along with very good martinis.
A favorite of ours.
Place rating: 5
Kaukauna, WI
Pizza is my passion, and Wiseguys is my newest favorite place for pizza! The service was EXCELLENT, the atmosphere, EXCELLENT, food, EXCELLENT! Three thumbs up! And such unique pizzas that you can’t go wrong with what you get. I only suggest they get a wheel barrel to haul people out!
Place rating: 5
Appleton, WI
Outstanding food and staff a family favorite
Place rating: 4
Oshkosh, WI
One word sums up this place. Atmosphere! The restaurant is great inside, thanks to the decorating details, and they were playing some great music the day we were there to continue our pizza challenge. We got a table in this little nook area next to the front window and it was an enjoyable dining experience.
The menu has a large selection of pizza to try and I was almost tempted to try one that isn’t our standard! But we ordered the standard and the pizza was delicious. One downfall was too much cornmeal on the bottom of the crust.
Next time I want to try the chica. Oh another plus is they have zesty or mild sauce red sauce and a few others to pick from if you build your own pizza.
It is in a strip mall and can be easy to drive past but worth looking for.
Place rating: 5
Appleton, WI
Great atmosphere and fantastic pizza. From the outside of building, does not look like much. Get inside and be amazed.