Lily Flanagan’s Pub

Great food, great beer, excellent staff!

Average food. Never had a bad experience, but was never really knocked off my seat. Happy hour is a good time though. Usually put out edible food and decent drink specials. Have a good burger here on Mondays. Tap beer though is often flat or stale. They are also a little pricey, but for Babylon it is what it is. $ 7.00 for a Blue Point is a little much in my opinion.

Our party in the upstairs room was great! The room was perfect and all our guests were impressed with everything from the room, great sangria to the delicious assortment of food we had. We had a brunch buffet and the entrees were delicious! The staff was friendly and professional. Our guests were very happy and keep commenting on the nice place and time they had there. Thank you Lily Flanagan’s!

Great atmosphere! 3 bars. They had a great band there! Bus Duty… Not the first time here, definitely not gonna be my last! The shepherd pie dinner is a recommendation if you feel the need to have some food! Very tasty and satisfying … Overall great date night place!

the wife and I went dancing there this weekend and had a blast!!! Great place, young crowds but friendly and fun

Went here for my birthday celebration with 8 other women. Food was great, server Jole was super friendly and food was immediately — no wait. Drinks were great and the bill was very reasonable. After dinner we danced to the DJ’s music which was great. I danced all night long! Will definitely be returning. Love this place!

This place is a serious dump. I went last Saturday night for my best friend’s birthday, and I immediately wished we found legitimately anything else to do instead. The bouncers are self entitled jerks that I think get some kind of sick pleasure at exercising their physical size and limited power to be complete asses. My friend, who wasn’t causing any problems or issues, who is also only 5’7″, was removed for no reason at the bar. This apparently warranted 3 of Lily’s finest half-​wit gorillas, one of whom also felt it necessary to shove me, at 5’6″, against the bar when I was trying to seek answers. I bought a dirty Shirley Temple for $ 6 that maybe had enough alcohol in it to clean a paper cut and nothing else. For the $ 5 cover that I had to pay and the price of that pathetic drink, I would rather pay someone to peel off my fingernails and then soak them in vinegar than to ever set foot inside of this garbage fire of an establishment. The owners should be ashamed of themselves.

Food was awesome! Our server Alana, was attentive and on point! Great filet mignon! Definitely will be back!

Came here for my birthday dinner (and I’m not sure why). The service was HORRIBLE, our waitress never came back to check on us– empty drinks for 10+ mins. I ordered a $ 26 dollar steak MW, it came out Medium Rare– Medium. I will never come here again! Food was gross, service was awful.

Went last night for dinner food is decent nothing to rave about, stay away from the blarney roll if you know whats good for you .The Staff was very friendly and service was great our waitress could not have been nicer thats why I gave them four stars. Great Salads and burgers !

We were automatically turned down at the door because one of us was wearing a hat. He took his hat off and the bouncer didn’t let us in bc of ripped jeans. This is a bullshit bar on long Island. It’s not a big deal. The bouncer didn’t even look at us, he was on his phone the entire time. Did they turn us down because we aren’t white?

I have been here numerous times and I have to say WHAT HAS HAPPENED TO IT. this place used to be very good.
First it was a Saturday night and they force you to valet park, the place was dead maybe 5 tables that’s it and my wife is handicapped so waiting for our car is not an option as far as im concerned and they set up there chairs in the handicapped spot. …
Next they brought over 2 rolls for the two of us using 2 dishes, no bread basket with 2 dishes and they were stale warm but hard as a rock almost broke my teeth…
I ordered seafood chowder and shepherd’s pie. the chowder was the only good thing brought to our table. the shepherd’s pie was dry and to me its kind of hard to mess that up but they did. the wife had a chicken dish that was supposed to have Prosciutto in it, but it was made with corned beef and then the waitress said oh no its made with Prosciutto, well it wasnt.
service wasn’t that great had to wait awhile to place an order.
my guess is they are not doing well so they are cutting back on things and swapping out ingredients with cheaper ones hoping no one will notice. well we noticed…
the only other good thing that night was the irish music which I love.
looks like the last time we will go there, I will take the ½ hour drive to islip next time to the best irish pub on the island in my opinion…

We came here for the 1^st time tonight. It was excellent. We tried the beer sampler. It was a good selection of 3 Oktoberfest beers. We liked them all. I had the corned beef and cabbage and my boyfriend had the filet mignon special. His steak was cooked perfectly and my dinner was great as well. Claire was our waitress and she was lovely. She answered all of our questions and gave us just the right amount of attention. We definitely will be back!

I came out here on a Friday night with some co-​workers. Thinking this was going to just be a warm up since it was our first stop, we grabbed some beers, some shots, and I ordered a chicken quesadilla. The quesadilla was pretty big, big enough to split, and it came stocked with all the sides (sour cream, pico, cilantro, and guaccc!).
Being a beer snob, this place looked like it had some decent beers on tap, but everytime I went to order one, it seemed to be out or there was something wrong with the lines… this forced me into taking advantage of the two-​fers on Bud Lights that started at 9pm. 2 for $ 5? Not too shabby!
We first got there around 7pm and the crowd was a older and there was a band playing. Somewhere between 9:59 and 10pm, it was a very yound crowd and the DJ started spinning. They also had an outside area which was perfect to hang out on before it got packed. I haven’t danced that much in a LONG time! The DJ killed it, lots of throwbacks mixed in with current hits. It was definitely a fun time!

Decent apps. Loved the Thai calamari. Entrees are extreme mediocre even for a pub.

I have been here a total of 3 times. I obviously came back because i thought it was a great restaurant. Before I say anything else I must say– the short ribs are AMAZING and so is their Irish coffee (I get it without alcohol because they make it a different way than regular coffee and its delicious). The portions for entrees are huge. So worth the price. I always take leftovers home.
One thing which is always a bummer is that the service is inconsistent. The first time I was there on a Wednesday and had a great server. Second time was there on a Saturday and my server was also good. My third server on a Friday was pretty terrible. Didn’t check on us during apps or salad, and shared maybe 5 words total with us. Not friendly at all. She probably wasn’t happy with the tip we left her.
They play live music which is cool, guys with guitars playing cover songs that may interact with the crowd. Pretty cool.
They have great
deals that save you a bunch too.
Overall I will continue to come here, but with hopes that I get a good server.

Good food/​good club decent drinks nice staff but they have no qualms about making you feel like it’s getting time to club lets go. My family was eating dinner there and they started moving the furniture around us. I know you have to but we were already paying and just about to get up it seemed a little rude. But as s club it’s pretty awesome

I mean eh this place wasn’t good but it wasn’t bad either, the music was okay, the crowd was nice. I would come here again, it didn’t wow me. It’s just your average dive bar in Long Island.

I’m writing this review strictly having partaken in the after hours scene for several years. I have come here for years, usually on the weekends with friends. The weekends are usually host to a younger crowd (between 18 and 25.) There is always an awesome DJ and the place gets packed out. There is always some kind of drink specialty deal happening, and despite the size of the crowd, the bartenders do a very good job of being attentive to customers. Sadly for me, I think I might have to start partaking in the earlier hours here and awesome dinners I hear about, because I think I am approaching the age where I am too old for the weekend crowd :(
I think the cool thing about Lily’s is that they do somehow reach a wide age range of people. I have come here as a 21 year old and bragged about what a great night I had, and my parents in their 50’s also have come away bragging about their great night at Lily’s. Again, I cannot speak for the dinners and early hour occurrences. But, if you’re in your early — mid twenties and looking to have a fun drunken night with lots of dancing and strangers to meet, this is your place! I’ve never had a bad night here. I deduct one star because the female bartenders have a tendency to talk down to their customers, even when you are not being a drunken, annoying mess.

Lily’s is great period. Real warm hospitality and never had a bad meal here once. I definitely prefer this location over the Islip one.
St Patrick’s Day is of the chain here. Always have a blast as Lily’s goes hard core Irish-​style! Lily’s does a proper Irish Car Bomb which is a must for anyone new to lily’s. Treat yourself to one… so good!
Menu covers all the Irish classics and prepares them in a home-​cooked comfort tradition. I enthusiastically recommend Lily’s to anyone who wants a homey Irish hospitable dining experience.