The Egg Toss Bakery Cafe

Bayfield, United States

4.6

Closed now

20 reviews

Accepts Credit Cards

Contacts

QR code, vCard

Telephone:
+1 715-779-5181
Website:
www.eggtoss-bayfield.com
Address:
41 Manypenny Ave, Bayfield, WI, 54814
Categories:
QR code
Download QR Image Download vCard

Map

Streetview

Activate map

Bussiness info

Takes Reservations
No
Delivery
No
Take-out
Yes
Accepts Credit Cards
Yes
Good For
Breakfast, Brunch
Parking
Street, Private Lot
Bike Parking
Yes
Wheelchair Accessible
Yes
Good for Kids
Yes
Good for Groups
Yes
Attire
Casual
Ambience
Casual
Noise Level
Average
Alcohol
Full Bar
Outdoor Seating
No
Wi-Fi
No
Has TV
No
Dogs Allowed
No
Waiter Service
Yes

Today

Today 6:00 am – 1:00 pm
Closed now
Local time (Bayfield) 11:37 PM Monday, June 9, 2025

Business hours

Monday 6:00 am – 1:00 pm
Tuesday 6:00 am – 1:00 pm
Wednesday 6:00 am – 1:00 pm
Thursday 6:00 am – 1:00 pm
Friday 6:00 am – 1:00 pm
Saturday 6:00 am – 1:00 pm
Sunday 6:00 am – 1:00 pm

Description

Specialties

«Breakfast favorites» and the best Eggs Benny in Bayfield! Daily specials, bottomless cup of coffee, Bloody Mary’s, fresh baked Artisan breads and bakery daily. Enclosed deck dining.

History

Established in 1996.

One of the three restaurants of Flamingos Up North

Vicinity

Near this location:
90
ft
What Goes ‘Round
38 S 2nd St
90
ft
Stone’s Throw
40 S 2nd St
430
ft
Big Water Coffee Roasters - Cooperative
117 Rittenhouse Ave
460
ft
Rum Line
31 S 1st
480
ft
Apostle Islands Booksellers
112 Rittenhouse Ave
490
ft
The Fat Radish
200 Rittenhouse Ave

20 reviews of The Egg Toss Bakery Cafe

No registration required
Place rating: 4
Rhinelander, WI
Super cute location with a not so typical breakfast menu. More than your average bacon and eggs. Family friendly. Go off season if you don’t want to wait for a table.
Place rating: 4
Webster City, IA
Nice friendly dining experience. Eggs Benedict with smoked trout was fantastic! Had to share our table with a couple from Kansas as setting was limited this morning. Popular spot for breakfast. Friendly wait staff. Hot cup of coffee that never emptied.
Place rating: 5
Portland, OR
Tasty breakfasts! Sizeable portions for scramble with smokey bacon. Perfectly prepared hash browns and buckwheat pancake. Good service and quaint homey décor.
Place rating: 4
Saint Paul, MN
Simple diner style breakfast joint. As a fan of eggs benedict i opted for the classic preparation. Perfectly prepared, quite possibly the best Eggs Benny I’ve had to date.
Fun atmosphere, good coffee and great service.
Place rating: 5
Minneapolis, MN
The best meal in Bayfield. I usually don’t order biscuits and gravy because my wife’s recipe is crazy good. Boy did you show up for some serious competition! Shhhhhhhhh… don’t tell her, but you may have just out-​cooked her! My oh my. Spicy. Yummy. Perfection. Fast and kind service. Wonderful sunny and open atmosphere. This is a must visit for Bayfield visitors!
Place rating: 5
Long Lake, MN
I would catch a grenade for these biscuits! Friendly staff. Maybe a wee bit too much black pepper in my sausage gravy.
Place rating: 4
Normal, IL
I am an eggs benedict kinda gal. They have several choices for this. I picked the crab cake benedict. It was sooo good. I’m not kidding. the poached egg was done perfect and the cakes were amazing. Service wasn’t great but the food was outstanding and the bread was really good.
Place rating: 5
Green Bay, WI
Love this place! Excellent food and fantastic service! I ordered the bagel and egg sandwich. It came with bacon and potatoes. The portions were really generous. The coffee at this place was top-​notch. I highly recommend coming here for breakfast. The gorgeous backdrop of Lake Superior gives the perfect relaxing feel to eating here. We loved our waitress, who was cheerful and gave us recommendations as to what to order. The food arrived to us in a timely manner. Our waitress came back to refill our coffees and told us a few facts about the economy of Bayfield as well as what it’s like there year-​round. There is a lot of seating by the windows and I definitely plan on returning here next time. It was just a wonderful place and seems like the employees love working here. There seems to be a nice sense of pride at this restaurant. Five stars for sure!
Place rating: 5
Orlando, FL
I love this place. Whenever I go to bayfield I come to the egg toss for great service, food and atmosphere only bayfield can deliver!
Place rating: 5
Carnation, WA
Great portions, excellent fresh ingredients, sat at counter by window to kitchen, saw amazing meals coming out. Pecan roll looked amazing, huge egg white omelets, my buckwheat pancakes with fresh organic maple syrup were outstanding. Get here early for breakfast to avoid a wait.
Place rating: 4
Fayetteville, AR
Great place to start your day. The wild rice and mushrooms omelette special was awesome. Daily specials are creative and delicious.
Place rating: 5
Scottsdale, AZ
Come with a hearty appetite and ready to eat brunch. Portions are very generous and the quality of the food is very good. Staff are very friendly and all around a good small town breakfast experience. There is also a good choice on the menu for all tastes from healthy to decadent and we found them very willing to make substitutions. Had the Orchard platter and give it two thumbs up.
Place rating: 5
Madison, WI
Lovely café and excellent service with home made food. So good. Highly recommend. We could t find better place to have breakfast
Place rating: 5
Roseburg, OR
Great food! There is a lot of love put into creating the meals, and it shows. Friendly, attentive, and patient staff. Corned beef hash is made from scratch, sausage is fresh (definitely not store-bought…or if it is, I need to know where they got it!), and they have fresh picked fruit! Better get there early… it fills up fast on a Saturday morning.
Place rating: 5
Harrison charter Township, MI
Bacon scrambler was delicious! HUGE portions! Friendly and great service! A must when in Bayfield!
Place rating: 5
Milwaukee, WI
Kudos to the Egg Toss for offering half portions! I’m an average-​sized lady with a normal appetite. I’m hesitant to return to places that force ridiculous, ginormous meals on everybody because wasting food should be criminal. Keeping leftovers is a concern, particularly for vacationers.
Anyhow, the food here was just right. I had the blood orange mimosa and the half crabby benny and it was absolutely perfect. My husband had the queen’s huevos rancheros and a bloody. It was so delicious, we’re considering coming back again tomorrow.
Place rating: 4
Neenah, WI
It’s hard to screw up breakfast. Ate here twice while vacationing in Bayfield. Didn’t fall in love with the huevos rancheros, as they lacked a Mexican flair. The veggie omelet was stuffed full of veggies. The bacon was thick and crisp and breakfast was served with a side of local raspberry jam which was tasty.
Place rating: 4
Amery, WI
The first morning, my husband and I had eggs and pancakes. The buckwheat pancakes were really fluffy and tasty. Great breakfast!
The next morning I decided to get the Crabby Benny. It was incredible! The crabcakes were a little bit spicy and the eggs/​hollandaise were really creamy. I definitely recommend it!
Place rating: 4
Park Falls, WI
I have been to Bayfield many times and I went to Egg Toss for the first time recently. The breakfast was exceptionally good. I had the Queen’s Huevos Rancheros and it was tasty indeed.
It is very crowded on weekends, which is to be expected, but worth the wait. HOWEVER, you would think with such a good coffee roaster just a few blocks away that their coffee would be excellent. It is NOT! :(Get some of the local coffee and the rating would be 5 stars from me. The coffee left me a little down– and I went to find some good stuff!
Place rating: 4
Milwaukee, WI
There are not a lot options for breakfast in Bayfield in the winter. We stopped at Egg Toss while waiting for the ice caves to open up. We were greeted by several smiling faces and a case of beautiful cake donuts!
I had the half order of the biscuits and gravy. I have yet to find a place in Wisconsin that makes good biscuits and gravy until now. The biscuit was a bit crisp on the outside and the inside was light and buttery. The gravy I could smother on everything if I could. The gravy is peppery and do flavorful. Of course I had to have a cake donut. So good!!!