Sigler’s Rotisserie & Seafood

I thought it was fine dining it felt more like fine dining prices with diner food and service. I was let down after great expectations from what I had read. Food and atmosphere were not bad just not worth the price.

Another INCREDIBLE meal tonight with my family. The Prime Rib is quite simply the best you will ever have. My brother had Seafood Pasta Diablo and my sister-​in-​law had the crab encrusted Salmon… both were off the chart good. The chocolate bread pudding dessert was probably one of the best desserts I’ve ever had… and it was part of the early bird dinner which is an incredible value. Our server Daryl was great… everything came out quick and he is such a pleasure to have as a waiter… we ask for him every time we go. Can’t recommend this place enough.

Wow! What an incredible find!!! Great service, excellent quality and delicious food. These folks know what good foods are. Fresh, perfectly cooked and very satisfying. I hope we pass by this way again!

This place does have the best atmosphere. Staff is polite and friendly. Seemed our wait on the main entrees were longer than it should be. Bread and salad was awesome. I wasn’t crazy about my shrimp dinner, however I’m not a fan or a red pasta sauce with shrimp.
Not sure what the pumpkin cheesecake will taste like, but we did get the early bird special.

Wow. Best meal I’ve had in Bluffton. Been here for almost 2 years. My parents recently went here and said they had a great meal. The décor is a bit dated, like the 80s banquet chairs and the old lighting, but the food. Man it’s good. Got a fillet that was such high quality and they melt a homemade garlic butter on it that you taste the entire time you’re eating. The staff was super friendly, but the flavor of that food! Kudos to the chefs, and thanks for a great meal. I hope you do a redesign of the interior in the near future.

Great place! Amazing staff, the food is unforgettable, and the atmosphere is great! Will definitely go there again. I ordered the Monday special, prime rib. Best prime rib I’ve ever had! Melted in my mouth. Our waitress was very nice and quick and helpful!

Husband and wife team make this little gem a success. I’ve named this my favorite in the area for the past 10 years now and have yet to have anything other than an excellent meal.

Sigler’s was a great choice for my 63^rd B’day. Enjoyed the seafood sampler and my main entrée but I have to rave over the excellent wine list. Best I have found yet in the low country. i

We are from out of town and wanted fried calamari. This was a great choice! We also had soup, salad and prime rib. .all were excellent! The food was great as was the service. Thank you!

Nestled in a small plaza, the inside is quite roomy and welcoming. The hostess was very warm and friendly talking to us as she walked us to our table.
We dined as a table of 8 and all the food looked fantastic! After taking our order, the waiter brought out bread and butter as well as pita and humus. We all got the 3 course early bird meal and it didn’t disappoint. The first course of salads and soups tasted fresh and light. My entrée of almond flounder was amazing and the prime rib at the table looked absolutely mouth watering.
Topping it all off was some delicious apple pie. The apples were harder than expected, but that didn’t detract from the sweet ending to a great meal. For the price of the early bird menu, this is a steal. Will definitely be back here next year when we make out annual trip down south!

We make a point to go to Sigler’s every time we come to Bluffton. The food is always delicious and we’ve never had a bad experience.

The food here is delicious and high quality. Our server, Graham, was wonderful. Very attentive and knowledgeable about the menu. The décor is also very charming. I highly recommend this restaurant!

Came up for the weekend from Gainesville, Fl for the Seafood festival. Has to be right at the top of eating experiences I’ve had.

Waiter was arrogant slow with an attitude, food was excellent and hostess was superior. When this server is taught the importance of a customer one or two stars could be added. People are to be served from left not across the table in front of the face of other diners and B/​S lets food get cold tipping should be with held then the message will be clear, even if this is owner.

Excellent seafood, steak and desserts. Great service and friendly staff. A must visit in Hilton Head/​Bluffton.

So sad to say this place went downhill :(On my last visit we had the prixe fixe menu and the entire thing was awful — except the cheesecake which was amazing. that’s why I give it 2 stars not 1. I mean, my seafood pasta was not even edible. So I am just turned off by this restaurant and probably wont go back.

Great German food and more. Their mussels and osso bucco are really outstanding. There is only one issue I have with this supposedly German place at October Fest, they don’t know what schweinshaxe is! Terrible oversight. It is a traditional October Fest treat. Had to settle for osso busco which is similar. Otherwise great for dinner. Seniors from Sun City get special treatment. They have a private room for groups. Service is very good, staff is knowledgeable about food, specials and beer and wine. Friendly owner greets you at the door. But don’t ask her about schweinshaxe.

With the help of Unilocal,and a few local friends who recommended Siglers, we decided to give it a whirl. We called ahead and made a reservation (a must on Friday nights and during their peak season.) We arrived a little earlier than our seating, so we grabbed a drink from the bar. As soon as our table was available, we were whisked to our seats.
We were quickly greeted by our waiter for the evening, Darryl, who filled us in on any specials that they were having. (All of which sounded divine!) While I was sipping a local brew at the bar, I had spotted a plate that came out… and I knew at that second that it what I was going to order. It was the Osso Bucco… A delicious pork cut that was cooked with a glaze, and sat on top of smashed potatoes and winter vegetables. The presentation, on all of the plates that were served at our table were top notch. We had a variety of selections: Prime Rib, Bluffton Seafood Broil, Mussels and Beef Roladen. We topped of the night with the Banans Foster with bread pudding. This didn’t disappoint either. Was probably the best bread pudding that I have ever had.

If you are looking for a place for a great meal, and a casual atmosphere… Sigler’s is your place. I can’t wait to get back there in the spring to visit again.

While visiting Hilton Head this fall, we found that Siglers’s was featuring an Octoberfest menu so we had to give it a try.
From the outside, it looks like a small non-​assuming strip mall place but walk inside to a warm welcome and charming old-​world décor. Service is outstanding (thanks Lea!) and the food was really good. Two of my dinner companions had the pork schnitzel and a third and the German «sampler» with rotisserie chicken, pork, two types of sausages, spatzel and red cabbage. Since so much food was being ordered, I had a Manhattan style seafood chowder and a grilled romaine summer salad. Everyone raved about there food.
The best was still to come, however. We ordered two desserts, a banana foster bread pudding with fresh fruit and home made vanilla ice cream and the best ice cream, black walnut, that I have ever had. That is high praise from a girl from Wisconsin! (They offered at least 4 favors of ice cream.)
Siglers is certainly worth the trip.

I rarely if ever give 5 stars to a place but this location has everything packed into it. Its located in a little business park behind a Sonic’s and KFC, but don’t let that fool you. Once you go inside, you know you’re in a really nice place even though you may feel underdressed for it. But don’t worry about it, the hostess (I believe to be the wife of the chef) makes you feel like you’re at their home. She is just so sweet.
This was the first place my husband and I dined at when we moved here from the west coast. Luckily, we were in time to make it for their early dinner menu. For about $ 17 for the each of us, we get an appetizer, main course, and dessert. The menu is the same is posted on their website, but everything on there still makes my tummy very happy every time we go. You cannot go wrong for the price. I love their soups the most. The desserts are usually different as the chef makes them daily.
Even though we felt like the only young people there, their usual diners seem to be more senior level (with the area being more of a retirement location), I don’t care. The food and service is just too wonderful to pass up. This is a great place to for locals and tourists. =)