New York Pizza

Boston, United States

3.5

Open now

26 reviews

Accepts Credit Cards
Free Wi-Fi

Contacts

QR code, vCard

Telephone:
+1 617-266-7020
Website:
newyorkpizzaboston.com
Address:
435 Massachusetts Ave, Boston, MA, 02118
at Columbus Ave
Nearby public transportation stops & stations:
150 ftMassachusetts Ave @ Columbus Ave
490 ftMassachusetts Ave
510 ftMassachusetts Ave Sta - Inbound
Categories:
QR code
Download QR Image Download vCard

Map

Streetview

Activate map

Bussiness info

Takes Reservations
No
Delivery
Yes
Take-out
Yes
Accepts Credit Cards
Yes
Good For
Dinner, Late Night
Parking
Street
Bike Parking
Yes
Wheelchair Accessible
Yes
Good for Kids
Yes
Good for Groups
Yes
Attire
Casual
Ambience
Casual
Noise Level
Average
Alcohol
No
Outdoor Seating
No
Wi-Fi
Free
Has TV
Yes
Waiter Service
No
Drive-Thru
No
Caters
Yes

Today

Today 10:00 am – 2:00 am
Open now
Local time (Boston) 10:50 AM Friday, November 29, 2024

Business hours

Monday 10:00 am – 1:00 am
Tuesday 10:00 am – 1:00 am
Wednesday 10:00 am – 1:00 am
Thursday 10:00 am – 1:00 am
Friday 10:00 am – 2:00 am
Saturday 10:00 am – 2:00 am
Sunday 10:00 am – 1:00 am

Related places

You might also consider:
570
ft
Mangia Neapolitan Pizza
537 Columbus Ave
690
ft
Ronny’s Place
505 Massachusetts Ave (South End)
760
ft
South End Pizza & Grill
772 Tremont St (South End)
1
mi
Uno Pizzeria & Grill
280 Huntington Ave
1
mi
Good Eats Pizza & Subs
1002 Tremont St
1
mi
Papa John’s Pizza
971 Tremont St

Vicinity

Browse nearby places:
10
ft
House of Culture
585 Columbus Ave
60
ft
Sovereign Bank
585 Columbus Ave
80
ft
Wally’s Cafe
427 Massachusetts Ave
120
ft
Shell Gas Station
584 Columbus Ave
130
ft
Chamber Theater Production Rehearsal Hall
584 Columbus Ave
140
ft
Darcys Barber Shop
430 Massachusetts Avenue

26 reviews of New York Pizza

No registration required
Place rating: 4
Alpharetta, GA
I wasn’t a fan of pizza until I bite on one of theirs. Love the soft chicken meat and thick layer of cheese. This little bar 2 minutes walk from my apartment become one of my favorite places to fill my stomach.
I didn’t give it a 5 star because of the poor service… Maybe it’s part of their service culture but I don’t like it.
Place rating: 3
Jamaica Plain, MA
I work nearby so I’ve tried this place a couple times for lunch. The first time I walked in and ordered a salad and waited for it. It took over 30 minutes to make a salad with grilled chicken. It was a good salad, but I was a little annoyed it took so long. Figured I’d give them another try and ordered online so I did’t have to use up most of my lunch hour. I ordered and never got anything saying when my order would be ready. I kept checking the status and it said «preparing your order» for about 45 minutes. Finally I called and asked if my order was ready and they sounded confused. When I told them what my order was, they said it would be ready in 5 minutes… it was just a small cold tuna sub, so clearly they hadn’t even started it yet. Overall the food was good but they’re REALLY slow and not worth it when Good Eats is right around the corner.
Place rating: 4
Millis, MA
I gave lousy review last time but I ‘d like to change my opinion
I am eating a slice of pizza now and love it.
My experience with there chicken salads was excellent!
Eli always does his best to make me a happy customer.
Ome night I had an unfortunate experience with a sub but I was assured today they would make me happy in the future
Good people
Good food
Place rating: 5
Phoenix, AZ
This place was down the street from where we stayed during our trip to Boston. Loved that they had extended hours because EVERYTHING was closed in the area by the time we got back from sight seeing. The pizza was awesome (loved the crust) and my husband loved the spaghetti and meatballs!
Place rating: 3
Boston, MA
It’s convenient to the South End for a quick bite. I would say the food and pizza is decent.
Place rating: 1
Dorchester, MA
If I could give zero stars I would pizza tasted like soap /​/​windex so I went back for a refund and then after he gave me the money he said a smart remark like I ate the whole pizza. I only took 3 bites people smh so then I responded I wouldn’t have walked back if it didn’t taste like soap and clearly the third bite confirmed it. Like as a staff of someone comes back as says your pizza tastes likeSOAP do something to change that stop spraying down counters when the food is out so it won’t be exposed to the chemicals.
Place rating: 3
West Chester, PA
Great late night pizza. If the slices were still $ 3, it would be 4 stars. I haven’t eaten other foods here, but I can vouch for the pizza if you like thin crust.
Place rating: 3
Rochester, NY
NY Pizza is a go to after a night out. The slices are huge and pretty cheap! Delivery from them is just okay. Usually it is pretty quick but the food doesn’t seem to travel well. I mean you can’t really mess up the pizza but any other food: mozz sticks, fries, burgers, etc. are just meh. Also, avoid the chicken parm pizza. Its just regular cheese pizza with hunks of chicken on it.
Place rating: 4
Boston, MA
Basics:
Their slices are huge and well-​priced! The crust is amazzzzzing.
More thoughts:
I’ve had their slices and ordered pizzas different times, and we have enjoyed the freshly made pizzas a little more, so if you’re going to get a few slices, I’d recommend ordering a whole pizza!
This place is our go-​to for pizza on a night we don’t feel like cooking, and it’s perfect for us because it’s close to our apartment.
Final Note:
The Upper Crust on Tremont is a bomb pizza spot in South End, but NYP is great for a convenient, reliable, and humongous slice.
Place rating: 4
Boston, MA
A nice thin slice of New York Pizza is what I expected coming to this location and that is exactly what I received. Even though I think the prices are a little on the high side because from Sasha you can get the same size pizza for $ 3. Not the best bargain but yet a decent slice of pizza is what you get from New York Pizza
Place rating: 2
Chicago, IL
Oh dear. The pizza. The foundation of the slice was all wrong. All wrong. It was paper thin (i.e. extremely weak and flimsy). It was quite literally no thicker than the cheap paper plates on which it sat. This paper thinness made it incredibly difficult to handle/​eat. I call it «struggle crust.» The top part/​edge was decent. The sauce was way way too sweet, though. The foundation on which all of the various ingredients sat seemed to compromise the slice from the start. I mean: they pile on all of that cheese, heavy sausages, veggies, and sauce, and that only serves to weigh down the already struggling crust underneath. I ended up asking for a fork, eating the toppings off therewith, and trashing the rest. What a waste of money. I gave them two stars because the top crust was decent and the customer service was ok.
Place rating: 5
Shrewsbury, MA
The pizzas were great. They have a minimum of $ 10 for credit cards
Place rating: 2
Lamott, PA
I’ve gotten pizza before and it’s been fine. Abnormally huge slices great for when you’re drunk, etc.
Had my first chicken parm grinder from here today and can say that I’ll never go back. Was almost not edible, could not even bite into multiple pieces of chicken. Definitely don’t trust it anymore.
Place rating: 3
Boston, MA
Went here to grab a slice of pizza after a night out. It was pretty late (after 1am), but thankfully they were still open.
We went right to the counter and were walking out with hot slices of pizza in under a minute.
The slice of pizza is pretty large and quite good for what it is. The crust is actually very good and the rest of the toppings are decent as well.
What I like about this place is that they just serve you lukewarm pizza, rather than putting it in the over for a couple minutes – which to me just makes it too hot and oily to eat.
Overall, no frills here but a great spot to get a late night bite.
Place rating: 5
Reading, PA
The biggest slice in Boston for under $ 5. And absolutely DELICIOUS crust too! Went to see Blue Man Group and they suggested this joint for our college budget and our hungry stomachs.
Place rating: 2
Boston, MA
The food is good but the location feels dangerous.
My friends call this place the «stab and slice» because you may get stabbed looking for a slice of pizza. Hahaha
But for real the pizza is OK. Not worth a special trip but if your hungry and already passing by grab a slice.
Place rating: 5
Boston, MA
NYP is a thoroughly satisfying pizza experience. We like to come here after going out drinking on our way home. The slices are MASSIVE and so delicious, from the variety of toppings to the plethora of cheese to the tasty sauce to the chewy sweet dough.
Service is always friendly and fast (which is great when you are dying for that slice at 1 in the morning) and I thoroughly look forward to getting a slice here every once in a while.
Place rating: 5
Boston, MA
Probably the best chicken greek salad and pizza I have ever had.
If you are a fan of doughy crust/​pizza check this place out. They have an ecclectic variety and their slices are huge.
Place rating: 2
Reno, NV
shouldnt be called new york pizza as that’s a laugher and injustice to the state of new york and their reputation for pies
these slices are huge yes they are but the sauce cheese and doughy crust downright disgusting
the dollar slices all around nyc puts these slices to shame
if ya must ya must
Place rating: 2
Boston, MA
Disappointing. I had been looking forward to trying a steak and cheese sub from this spot and finally made the trip only to be dissatisfied. I ordered a steak and cheese sub with onions cooked in the meat, bread toasted, mayo, lettuce, pickles and hots. However, I could barely taste the garnishes. The meat was bland and the presentation overall was lacking specific to my order. Won’t be going back anytime soon or more like at all. #foodcravingsunfulfilled
Place rating: 5
Surfside Beach, SC
Slices are huge! Dough is nice and light and very tasty. I went for the BBQ chicken slice with French fries on it. Delicious and nutritious. Cost of food very fair for quality and speed of service. Great variety of slices available.
Place rating: 1
Boston, MA
I ordered a $ 4.50 slice of pizza. Ignoring the fact that the price is already too expensive, NYP would only accept a $ 10 credit card minimum… after they had already placed my slice in the oven and I had waited in line. I told them I didn’t have any cash, and they said «too bad, we don’t need you as a customer anyway.» Wow– good to know.
Place rating: 4
Harvard Square, Boston, MA
Best place to eat late night pizza. Huge pizza slices and good taste. Just a few minutes walk from Northeastern /​Berklee /​Mass Ave /​Symphony.
They only accept card over $ 10.
Place rating: 5
Maywood, NJ
Ok, so for just a little under ten bucks I got this wicked awesome chicken penne pasta in huge quantities! It was hot, fresh, cheesy, and really satisfied the pasta craving I had been having all week. They give you so much that I know I can squeeze two more meals out of my leftovers. I also love that they already give it to you in a foil box with a lid to make it easier to pack up when you’re finished instead of you having to transfer it into a to-​go box yourself. Oh, and they gave me plates/​forks and garlic bread in my bag, which I totally was not expecting! :)
Place rating: 4
Brockton, MA
Aight… mega slices of pizza.Fast. Pretty tasty… what else you want?
I would not say it’s the best… but it works.
Place rating: 3
Providence, RI
Exhibit six in «Everything tastes good with Alcohol.»
I wonder if anyone has actually stopped by NY Pizza completely sober in the middle of the afternoon. I haven’t. There are better pizzas in the city, and better pizzas within the surrounding *three blocks* (see Mangia Neapolitian), but it’s the only show in town after midnight.
And they deliver the goods, with plentiful tectonic-​sized sheets of hot, greasy pizza. Stay simple with toppings and increase the chance of getting a freshly-​cooked slice — though the reheated specimens are okay as well. And don’t forget to dump a tower of grated cheese (to call it parmesan would be generous) and oregano.
No, they don’t serve booze.