Crosby Pizza Stop

Bronx, United States

4.2

Open now

20 reviews

Accepts Credit Cards

Contacts

QR code, vCard

Telephone:
+1 718-823-8980
Address:
1731 Crosby Ave, Bronx, NY, 10461
Pelham Bay
Nearby public transportation stops & stations:
350 ftBuhre Avenue
0.3 miMiddletown Road
0.5 miPelham Bay Park
Categories:
QR code
Download QR Image Download vCard

Map

Streetview

Activate map

Bussiness info

Takes Reservations
No
Delivery
Yes
Take-out
Yes
Accepts Credit Cards
Yes
Good For
Lunch, Dinner
Parking
Street
Bike Parking
Yes
Wheelchair Accessible
Yes
Good for Kids
Yes
Good for Groups
Yes
Attire
Casual
Noise Level
Average
Alcohol
No
Outdoor Seating
No
Wi-Fi
No
Has TV
Yes
Waiter Service
No
Caters
Yes

Today

Today 11:00 am – 10:00 pm
Open now
Local time (Bronx) 11:47 AM Wednesday, June 18, 2025

Business hours

Monday 11:00 am – 10:00 pm
Tuesday 11:00 am – 10:00 pm
Wednesday 11:00 am – 10:00 pm
Thursday 11:00 am – 10:00 pm
Friday 11:00 am – 10:00 pm
Saturday 11:00 am – 9:00 pm
Sunday 11:30 am – 9:00 pm

Description

Specialties

pizza heroes salads

History

Established in 1973.

crosby pizza was originaly opend in 1957 .

and later purchased by vincent leo current owner

in 1973. after working there for 4 y4ars

Meet the Business Owner

vincent L.

Business Owner

mysef have being making pizza for 45 years daniel is here for 23 years, and my other workers for ove 10 years

Related places

Explore similar places:
230
ft
Mangia’s Brick Oven Pizza and Pasta
1760 Crosby Ave (Pelham Bay)
550
ft
House of Pizza
3039 Buhre Ave (Pelham Bay)
610
ft
Pinocchio Pizza Restaurant
3039 Buhre Ave (Pelham Bay)
610
ft
Two Brothers Pizza
3039 Buhre Ave (Pelham Bay)
880
ft
Joe’s Pizza
3009A Middletown Rd (Country Club)
1
mi
Villa Barone Restaurant
3289 Westchester Ave

Vicinity

Near this location:
30
ft
Shamrock Inn
1729 Crosby Ave
50
ft
City & Suburban Federal Savings Bank
1745 Crosby Ave
70
ft
Oria Frank X Funeral Home
1727 Crosby Avenue
80
ft
Pelham Bay Dental Associates
1750 Crosby Ave
80
ft
Dunkin’ Donuts
1752 Crosby Ave
100
ft
Subway
1749 Crosby Ave

20 reviews of Crosby Pizza Stop

No registration required
Place rating: 5
White Plains, NY
Every item in the pizza shop is fantastic. Delivery is fast and hot. The prices are very good. Service is fsntastic. They really know what they’re doing in there. You know the food is good the same staff has been working there for as long as I can remember. I just wish they made dinners.
Place rating: 4
Bronx, NY
Pelham bays favorite pizza spot! Never had an issue with this place. Always fresh and delivery always on time.
Place rating: 5
Biloxi, MS
Excellent pizza. They always follow my specific requests as I am picky about my pizza! Two thumbs up
Place rating: 5
Hartsdale, NY
i have been coming here for over 20 years. And there have been changes. What started off as a place that sold Sicilians, Neopolatitan and Fried Calzones has evolved into a place that uses the best available ingredients to make truly fresh and delicious pies, artisans and calzones. You will never find them warming up yesterdays pizza to sell. That says a lot. Thats pride in what you sell and care for
Place rating: 4
Bronx, NY
I’ve come here and ordered delivery from here so many times, they know me by name. The pizza is really good. Probably one of the better spots in Pelham Bay. Always consistent with their flavor.
Place rating: 5
Bronx, NY
The pizza is the best in the neighborhood. Prices are reasonable the people are nice and the delivery is fast! You can get pepperoni added for no extra charge. We have also had their chicken parm heros and the panini which are also very good!
Place rating: 1
Middletown - Pelham Bay, NY
If I could give –1 star I would… I ordered a simple pepperoni pie & a 2 liter of ginger ale. I ended up waiting and hour to be handed a cold stale pizza by an indifferent delivery man that I only bought because I was starving! Mind you I live like 2 blocks away, & this jerk off was acting as if he was doing me a favor! Like I was in the mood for some stale ass cold pizza! It’s safe to say you folks lost my business. There’s way to many pizza shops in Pelham bay to settle for this crap
Place rating: 5
Bronx, NY
I Love there Pizza at Crosby Pizza Shop, there #1 :)
Place rating: 5
Bronx, NY
This place is awesome. I have not had a slice of pizza from here that I did not like. They have quite a few to choose from and they are always delicious. It’s always crowded, but understandably so. Delivery is quick and the guys are friendly. I love their pepperoni rolla and their pan chicken and tomatoes pizza. Highly recommend to anyone. My favorite pizza in the area
Place rating: 5
Bronx, NY
My parent use to bring me when I was a little girl. More then 10 years later still love it ! I’m always stuck between garlic knots, Mac n chess pizza and Sicilian. My three favorites. Oh and when I feel like being healthy salad pizza. :)
Place rating: 5
Bronx, NY
When it comes to pizza, I’m extremely picky. I’ve been to several spots around NYC and Westchester Cty, but since moving to Pelham, I’ve become obsessed with Crosby! Not only is the crust and quality fabulous, but the guys working there are really great (good looks and pizza!). Pricing is perfect and they are always timely with deliveries.
Place rating: 5
Bronx, NY
My family orders from Crosby Pizza pretty often and we love it. They have so many yummy specialty pizzas, and the round Sicilian is my absolute favorite. I’ve also gotten salads from here that were DELICIOUS. The staff is also always friendly and the service is quick.
Place rating: 5
Middletown - Pelham Bay, NY
Amazing every time! Huge slices, love the regular AND Sicilian, plain cheese and chicken cutlet are my favorite. Gotta get garlic knots too. And really good salad! So many good things to say about this place. I go every Friday!
Place rating: 4
Pelham Bay, Bronx, NY
Hands down, the best Sicilian pie around. It’s a round pie, but I think that adds to the flavor.
Place rating: 3
Bronx, NY
Despite what one may think about living in the bronx, it is not as easy as it sounds to find good pizza. We ventured into Crosby, and ordered something I thought was a thin crust Sicilian (grandma pie) which turned out to be something slightly different. Cant remember the name, but it was a tiny, yet dense 6 slices of deliciousness. Will return again.
Place rating: 2
Bronx, NY
Can’t take an order? Waited over an hour, guy says he came but noone answered, meanwhile I live in a doorman building. Didn’t listen on the phone for our address or telephone phone just rushed us off the phone.
Place rating: 4
Riverhead, NY
Best pizza around, there food doesn’t suck
Place rating: 5
Pelham, NY
Amazing pizza, try the round Sicilian
Place rating: 4
New York, NY
As long as you can make a decent cheese pizza, I don’t see a reason as to why you can’t be patronized.
Place rating: 3
Bronx, NY
This place is changing.
Vinny, one of the original pizza makers, is semi-​retired, and the pizza is only *really good* when Vinny is there. Otherwise, the pizza is adequate enough. A lot of local pizzerias have been going down the tubes in the past few years. This place is better than most.
The pizza is fresh, the garlic knots are on the doughy side, and the calzones are pretty good (as per my sister, since I don’t eat calzones). They don’t clean the tables often enough, so when you sit down don’t be surprised at the drops of grease sticking to the table. The staff is efficient and even when it’s crowded the wait time is pretty short. This place is always crowded on Fridays during Lent.
On the bright side, this is a good place to bring your outside-​NYC relatives to. They think this pizza is top notch. I guess taste is subjective depending on where you live.