A’mangiare

Order this grandpa garlic. Omg. You won’t be disappointed. The best in area the garlic and taste I think it’s perfect for a party as appetizer you can make bite sizes with your pizza cutter.

Food is excellent, however extremely pricey overall when compared to other local Italian eateries (i.e. Gino’s).
While we love the food and are willing to pay the fees we have been very disappointed with the service at times with multiple orders for pickup being incorrect and extremely long wait times for food.
On one occasion I witnessed the phone ringing continually, no one answering it, only to be picked off the receiver eventually, promptly hung up and the phone left off the hook to not allow additional calls. Now I don’t wonder why I always get a busy signal. Hey A’Mangiare, ever hear of an answering machine.
Bummer about this place as the food is good but probably won’t be back.

The pizza is always good but is definitely expensive so I don’t come here often, but I have tried their summer salad with walnuts, feta cheese, and fruits which are to die for, but my favorite is their butternut squash ravioli. They also always do a great job catering our office lunches

We live in Eastchester, just up the road a bit and have been to A’Mangiare quite a few times. So, what can I say here… Wife and I really enjoy eating here. We both come from Italian families so I’d say that we both really know Italian food.
We find the prices okay, but if they were higher, don’t think we’d ever go.
Wife and I try not to cook at home anymore if we can help it. As long as places like A’mangiare exist we will go…

I just want to thank A’Mangiare for doing a wonderful job on catering my parents anniversary party. What made the party so wonderful was the food. Everyone couldn’t stop complimenting us on the food we had from pizza to pasta and chicken and veal. Everything was excellent. We also had a few waitress that they sent over to serve and the girls went above and beyond. Thank you again for making our parents day so special !!

Hands down the worst Italian food I’ve ever had. This place has a menu like a bible – all of those choices and not one of them good. My friend and I ordered the stuffed artichoke to share, which was soggy and overheated. The fettucine al vodka was awful– the pasta was chewy and overcooked, and the sauce was watery and tasteless. I am certain that this place doesn’t employ chefs, just a squad of heating engineers. Don’t waste your time and money.

Yes this is so far the best Italian home cooked meal feel. The bread is soft and tasty the salads are good portion with great dressing and the chicken and Fish franchise are just so home cooked tasting don’t let the size of the place fool you… can’t wait to come back!

Great food! Lovely!
Ricotta cheese raviolis, strawberry spinach salad and chicken with pineapple, avocado and red pepper.
Really good guys!

The man who answers the phone for delivery orders is very challenged. I wouldn’t say this in a review if it hadn’t happened on several occasions. He seriously has a comprehension problem, despite my reading directly from their menu the name and description of each dish we wanted. Takes a good ten minutes to get through all aspects of ordering and then you’re not quite sure if you’re gonna get what you wanted. This is a really easy thing to fix, guys. Anyway, the food’s good. Just eat in house and you’ll be fine.

Definitely not what it used to be. Avoid the bolognese sauce; the meat is gray and it tastes like dog food. The delivery driver first said he left his change in the car, then came back and said he had no change on him (probably figured if he didn’t carry change people will be forced to tip him). I worked in a restaurant for almost 10 years, there’s no reason for a delivery driver not to have change on him. The only saving grace for this place was the fettucine a la vodka. Other than that we don’t need to order from here again.

Under new management. The pizza definitely doesn’t taste the same any more. Used to like their pizza. Pizza dough sucked. Sauce sucked taste like tomato juice too watery. Cheese was the same. Adding garlic or salt didn’t help. Sad to say I won’t be back.

Great food, challenged service.

This place has gone completely downhill. To start the sauce is disgusting. Tastes like cinnamon and sugar are added to make it sweet. Secondly, their quality of meat is horrible. It has a weird odor. Lastly the service sucks. When I ask for chicken cutlets to be thin and crispy, please don’t say that «it may not be possible». Oh I got a thick and fatty chicken cutlet. Thanks for nothing people. I will no longer order from this overly priced pizzeria.

I’ve been coming here for a few a years and initially I thought this place:
1) had great pizza
2) was kinda pretentious for only doing table service after 4 pm, considering it’s a pizza shop
Then we had dinner here. Hold up! This isn’t your average pizza place. Eggplant Fiorentina, Chicken Scarpariello, homemade desserts — all excellent. Il Bacio is pretty good but A’mangiare has them beat in my book. And it’s not just that they execute the basics well, there always seems to be something that makes their dishes that much better than the rest: pickled vegetables in the cold antipasto, fresh tomatoes in the Eggplant Fiorentina, the ricotta and olive tapenade you get with your bread. They usually have some interesting specials too.
You wouldn’t guess it’s as good as it is when you walk by the place. Their Pleasantville location is much more fitting for the quality of food they put out. But I’m happy they’re in Bronxville.

Great food been going here for years the only issue is trying to find parking! good pizza and they always have good specials.

They sent an apology letter with a free gift cert for a meal. I still wouldn’t ever order delivery ever again but I thought this was very classy and a nice touch by the owners.

Was in the area for work and the client took me here. Got the grandma, grandpa, and a cannoli. The grandpa was really good, huuge chunks of roasted garlic and the crust was just about perfect. The grandma was ok, wouldn’t recommend it specifically. The cannoli was really good, they are filled on demand so they never go soggy (the way all cannolis should be). I got one the chocolate dipped one, it was the only one I saw and they’re my favorite so I lucked out. I heard the buffalo chicken slices are really good as well.
Bottom line: If you are in the area, stop in for a grandpa and cannoli!

One of the better places you can go for lunch in Bronxville. Reasonable prices and filling portions from a menu with a lot of options.

The only reason I give this place one star is because there is no option for zero stars! (and our server was friendly). My boyfriend and I went for dinner last night. I was really hungry and pretty excited because everybody tells me how great A Mangiere is. Well, they must have been referring to the one in Elmsford, ONLY. The best pizza in Bronxville? Seriously??? This was not only the worst pizza in Bronxville but the worst pizza I have ever had. If you like Dominos, you’re in luck because that’s exactly what it tasted like. The sauce has absolutely no flavor. We had the A Mangiere Combo mini pizza and a chicken parm wedge to split. The chicken tasted like it was microwaved! It was so tough… and again the sauce. At least the cheese was good but what cheese isn’t good?
I would not recommend this place to anyone!

Pizza was thin, crispy and yummy. I started with a salad and a cup of lentil soup, which were good. The service was horrible, but I don’t expect much at a pizza joint.