Joey’s Seafood & Grill

The food is very good especially there jumbo lillalla, the service is very good always willing help out, the best time come here is all you can eat fish fry, on Tuesday nights the place is very clean

I’ve been here numerous times. My salmon came completely undone (raw) so the manager did take it back to be redone. It came back overdone in my opinion. Was offered a soup or salad for the inconvenience. Hopefully the kitchen problem will be fixed soon.

I’m still trying to like this place and I order something different from my disappointing choices from the past so I ordered the jerk chicken sandwich. There is no consistency to this place with the food and with work I’m stuck eating here at times so I’m trying find something I can like.
First off the jerk chicken sandwich didn’t really have any jerk flavor to it so with that being said here we go, see my pictures.
First impression after opening the box was what a great looking breast with some grill marks while juicy looking. It comes with frys and slaw to complete the order. It’s pretty simple with a slice of tomato and some lettuce on a toasted bun. The breast is an un adulterated whole piece of meat on the thick side which was nice.
When I took my first bite I didn’t taste any jerk flavor but I did taste a nice moist/​juicy seasoned chicken breast. This was probably the juiciest chicken breast I have ever had and not cooked to death. The texture and taste was just like when I brine chicken at home before cooking which surprised me because I have never had one outside my kitchen. Next time I would ask for mayo on it and it will become a nice fresh grilled chicken sandwich, maybe bacon to make it over the top.
We had take out for lunch at work so I’m not going to complain about the frys not being as good as dining in but they were seasoned well and are probably really good when very fresh.
Overall with not getting a good jerk chicken sandwich, the chicken sandwich was good none the less good and this is the best meal here so far for me.

Came in tonight looking for something different. Food was a 3 while service at the bar was a 4. Had a couple of tv’s so I could catch the Packer game. Excellent choice if you want to catch a game without being overwhelmed with a crowd.

We stopped in last night for dinner. My husband ordered the seafood creole and when it arrived it was ice cold, I mean refrigerator cold. Our server was very apologetic and took it back to the kitchen. It must have been pre-​made and then reheated as needed (which, in our case, never happened). The thing that got me was the owner/​manager never came over. He was in the kitchen and talked to the cooks, but then returned to sitting at the bar and appeared to be reading the newspaper. Not good customer relations if you ask me. I don’t know if he was embarrassed or didn’t believe us, but managers normally will follow up when customers have an issue.
The food was so-​so.
Our server was very attentive.
The manager was pathetic. Needless to say, that is something that will drive customers away — like us.
I would have rated Joey’s a zero, but that was not possible.

Food is really good. Be prepared to wait a long time, there was only about 6 other people in the restaurant and my food took almost an hour to cook and it wasn’t hot just warm
Bathroom could use some attention smells like a crab shack in there. Toilet paper mess on the floor

Food is blah. Poor service. Horrible music. No one there on a Saturday night. Would give it zero stars if I could.

Nice atmosphere and good food. I didnt like that we were within arm’s reach of people at the next table. I need my space but it is such a small location that I understand the close tables. The service was fast until it came time for the bill and the waiter disappeared. We sat with empty plates for over 10min.

Excellent service! The food was quite tasty. The cheddar bacon mashed potatoes were out of this world. Our daughter had the crab stuffed haddock and she said it was the best fish entrée she has ever had while dining out. The clam chowder was top notch as were the deep fried oysters. My husband had a roaster dinner with crab, oysters and clams. He enjoyed that as well. If we are ever back in the area we will certainly stop here again.

Very disappointed at this place. Only good thing was the nice waitress. Ordered the Dump dinner and yes it was a dump. The corn on the cob was frozen (I thought it actually was suppose to be cold) on all of our orders. I asked our waitress and she said all the tables had cold corn. Maybe they don’t check the temperature before it goes out.
The dish was very empty if they would of added one more sausage and extra onions and peppers. Just looked very plain. Sorry but I wouldn’t come back unless it was free to try it again. I’m all about second chances.

If it’s possible to have a more disinterested server, I’d like to learn how — I’m sorry I was just a «party of one» but after taking my order, it would have been nice to get my iced tea before my meal — nope, «Eric» couldn’t be bothered
Food took seemingly long to come out, but, as usual, it was good — and a good value — of course, there was no be back to check whether everything was ok, but the server did have the presence of mind to deliver my bill within 3 minutes of my food
Both of my kids have been servers — I tend to tip well — that isn’t going to happen today

Hostess and waitress were very attentive. I was underwhelmed by the presentation and quality of food. I ordered the stuffed shrimp with mixed veggies and red beans and rice. There was a hard particle in the cream sauce, the stuffing tasted old and over cooked, and the vegetables were not fresh. Again, the service was good, but the quality of food was not ideal.

My wife and I decided to try this place. I had a craving for some good seafood. She is not a seafood person but saw she could get a steak while I satisfied my seafood craving. She ordered a 12 oz sirloin steak and I ordered the «seafood dump» dinner. Her steak was not very good and looked like a lesser cut of meat. Mine consisted of snow crab, shrimp, mussels, potatoes and onions and green peppers. It also came with corn on the cob and Andouille sausage. The crab and the shrimp was ok but didn’t seem terribly fresh. It was not a fabulous meal by any means. I also ordered a bowl of clam chowder. That was a big mistake and was not very good. Our server was nice but seemed to take forever at times. My wife had the lemon cream cake for dessert. That was outstanding. This meal except for the dessert was very mediocre and will not be going back again.

The service was good along with the food! Would definitely come back for the Crab legs and the fish& chips

We’ve eaten here a number of times. The food is a notch above average and the prices are reasonable, especially with daily specials. But beware — they offer a deal through the Journal Sentinel DealWatch for $ 20 worth of food for $ 10. I bought one of these and presented it recently. They tried 3 times to refuse it, saying it didn’t apply to what we ordered (the limitiations are clearly printed on the voucher and only limit use on Mother’s Day and on All You Can Eat items), the voucher didn’t have a barcode (this voucher has a number, but doesn’t come with a barcode), and then that it didn’t apply to daily specials. Only after much gentle encouragement and embarrassment on my part did they huffily and reluctantly agree to honor the voucher. I notified DealWatch of this poor experience, which reflects on them also.
BTW, we dined during Happy Hour, but they also wouldn’t give us the menu Happy Hour price on drinks because we «weren’t sitting at the bar.» Unless you enjoy embarassment and argument, I suggest you avoid the DealWatch at Joey’s, and stick with places you feel you can trust.

If you are going here for great service, keep driving. If you like good food, then stop, unless you are ordering the mac and cheese for your kids. Then keep going. They serve Kraft Mac and Cheese for $ 5. Too bad it is not fresh.
And don’t forget your Entertainment book because they will not honor the app

I went there for the first time a few weeks ago. The fish fry was the worst. It looked like store bought frozen fish that they had deep fried. It was mushy on the inside and very greasy. There was more breading than fish. I was very disappointed because I expected more from a restaurant that has the word «seafood» in it’s name.

The food here is always outstanding and you get very hefty portions as well. I would choose this place over red lobster every time! For two people with drinks and an appetizer your looking at around $ 50 which is average for a seafood place like this. The only reason I gave it 3 stars is because the service is never the best. We have gotten the same guy every time and he ALWAYS forgets a drink or takes FOREVER to check back with our table. I am not hard to please when it comes to service but it gets old having to remind someone about your food and drinks everytime you go somewhere.

Ordered calamari. Had a decent kick to it but it was all very small pieces. Very rubbery. Not fresh or even a quality cut of calamari. Better than most though as it wasn’t heavily breaded.
Ordered the seafood Alfredo. First time out the noodles were mush. Sent it back and waited another 10 minutes for a repeat crap performance. The Alfredo doesn’t taste hirre but it’s hard to screw that up.
The bartender was very nice and apologetic and offered me free key lime pie. Love key lime pie. Got it to go.
I’ve had fish and chips here before which were good. Guess I should have stuck to that.

Awesome Wednesday fish fry special for $ 5.99. Great kids meals. My son loved the popcorn shrimp. Fries were extremely crisp and delicious. Door County Cherry Wheat beer on tap was very good. Nice cozy atmosphere with friendly and attentive wait staff. Will be back soon!